18/03/2026
The carnivore diet is often promoted with the claim that fiber is unnecessary for human health. From my 30-year practice perspective, this claim does not align with anthropology, physiology, nor my clinical experience.
There are situations where temporarily reducing fiber can help, particularly in small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO). In this condition, bacteria normally confined to the colon colonize the small intestine, where fermentation of carbohydrates and fiber can produce painful gas and bloating. Reducing fermentable foods can relieve symptoms.
Some people also feel better on carnivore-style diets because they remove plant-derived antigenic compounds and anti-nutritional factors (ANFs). In individuals with compromised gut integrity or autoimmune disease, reducing these exposures can decrease immune activation. For this reason, elimination diets — including carnivore or modified Paleo approaches — can serve as useful therapeutic tools.
But a therapeutic strategy should not automatically become a permanent diet. Long-term avoidance of fiber often leads to fragile digestion and growing intolerance to plant foods. There is also substantial evidence that fiber protects against colorectal cancer, a topic I will explore in more detail in a future post.
Another observation: many strict carnivore adherents report bowel movements every two to three days or longer. Across traditional medical systems, including Ayurveda, daily elimination has long been considered a fundamental marker: not just digestive health, but many aspects of wellness, including cognitive function.
Even before modern microbiome science, mothers and grandmothers understood something simple: plants are not optional in human nutrition. So remember: eat your vegetables!