05/02/2026
Self-compassion is widely recommended in psychology.
Yet for many people, it feels inaccessible or even distressing.
When someone holds a strongly binary moral identity, self-criticism can function as a way of maintaining safety, belonging, and control. Shame tends to create global negative identity beliefs, while guilt usually remains linked to behaviour. When these become fused, compassion toward the self can feel morally unsafe.
This is particularly relevant in individuals shaped by rigid moral or cultural frameworks where emotional expression, accountability, or personal responsibility are tightly regulated.
Therapeutic work often involves carefully expanding identity beyond binary categories, allowing accountability and self-respect to coexist with compassion.
Self-criticism rarely appears without history, meaning, or function. When these are understood, change becomes more possible and more stable.
If you recognise yourself here, you are not alone in this experience.
Comment GUIDE for my free guide “What’s Really Going On?” A Psychologist’s Guide to the Patterns Behind Your Pain.
And if you are ready to start your therapy journey, get in touch via the link in bio to enquire about therapy with a Counselling Psychologist in my practice. We would love to hear from you.