04/03/2025
Wise words.
Sadly, even some special schools do not understand this.
Do Schools Actually Like Children?
School behaviour policies are getting stricter by the yearâdetentions for being a minute late, isolation for wearing the wrong socks, and zero-tolerance rules for even minor infractions. But hereâs the question: do these policies show that schools like children, or just that they like control?
Many argue that clear rules help maintain order, create fairness, and prepare students for the real world. Schools often say that strict discipline ensures a focused learning environment where everyone can succeed. Zero-tolerance policies on bullying, firm uniform rules to reduce peer pressure, and punctuality expectations all aim to create structure and consistency. From this perspective, discipline isnât about being harshâitâs about setting children up for success.
But when policies become so rigid that they punish students for things beyond their control, are they really supporting children? Being given a detention for forgetting a pen or wearing the wrong shade of trousers doesnât necessarily teach responsibilityâit just creates frustration. And for students dealing with challenges outside school, such as difficult home lives, neurodiversity, or mental health struggles, strict policies can make school feel more like a battle than a place of learning.
If schools genuinely liked children, wouldnât they focus just as much on understanding them as they do on disciplining them? Some of the strictest rules donât seem to take individual circumstances into account. A child who is late because they had to take a younger sibling to school shouldnât be punished the same way as one who is late because they were hanging out with friends. Yet, in many schools, both would face the same consequences. Where is the compassion in that?
Strict behaviour policies also risk creating an environment where compliance is valued more than creativity, curiosity, or well-being. When children feel like they are constantly walking on eggshells, afraid of being punished for small mistakes, it doesnât make them more engaged in their educationâit makes them resent it. A school should be a place where children feel supported, not just controlled.
Of course, rules are necessary. No one is saying schools should allow chaos. But rules should serve students, not just the system. A school that truly likes children should be able to distinguish between discipline that helps and discipline that harms. It should focus on helping students grow, not just making them obey.