11/11/2025
Hoping to make things clearer not start awful comments. This is not a page for nastiness, this is my page for my enjoyment and education, if you don't agree then just scroll past or leave. I'm not in this world for the arguments, I am only here to make life as good as possible for my horses and this method saved Moo's life.
Q: If P3 rotation is caused by poor hoof care, can inflammation of the laminae still happen due to poor gut health or diet?
This is one of the most common and valid questions we hear from owners - and itâs an important one to clarify.
Our message has never been that horses canât have metabolic issues, or that digestion and diet donât affect their overall health. The point is that laminitis (as the world defines it) has been catastrophically misinterpreted.
If all a âwonky metabolismâ did was make a horse a bit footy, then under no circumstances would we see the epidemic of rotation, pe*******on, and osteonecrosis thatâs leading to horses being euthanised all over the world.
Horses arenât being put to sleep because theyâre âfooty.â Theyâre being lost because of hoof capsule divergence (HCD) - imbalance and deformation caused by incorrect hoof care - but thatâs still being called laminitis.
Even if metabolism somehow made the laminae mildly inflamed, it wouldnât tear or detach them, because we can now see that tearing and divergence are physical distortions, not chemical ones. The inflammation wouldnât (and doesnât) create separation on its own. The only consistent trigger for laminar tearing and capsule divergence is hoof imbalance.
And hereâs the crucial part:
đ There is no concrete evidence - not in research papers, not in field practice - that laminae become inflamed by anything other than distortion caused by HCD. No one, anywhere, has ever taken true baseline and sequential hoof measurements before claiming âmetabolic laminitis.â Without that data, any metabolic conclusion is meaningless, because the hoof variable - the single biggest factor - was never controlled.
Science turned away from the hoof because the hoof was complex, hard to measure, and not easily quantifiable. Instead, researchers turned to the blood, tissues and chemicals, because these can be measured in a lab. But that doesnât make it the cause. The first rule of science is to reduce variables, yet no study on metabolic laminitis has ever controlled for hoof balance, trim type, or capsule distortion.
Even more revealing, no metabolic study properly examined the hind feet or even compared both fronts. Blood (hormone imbalance) affects the whole body, yet supposed âmetabolicâ damage shows up differently between feet. That alone disproves the uniform systemic cause theory, because blood isn't choosy.
So when people worry that weâre âmissing the inflammation,â we can confidently say:
đ Weâre not missing it, weâve just correctly identified it. The inflammation is a symptom of hoof capsule divergence (HCD), not a separate "disease". The true epidemic isnât dietary, itâs hoof-care-driven pathology mislabelled as laminitis.
And this is where real change must begin.
For every horse said to be suffering from âdiet-related hoof issues,â the first step must be a critical, professional assessment of the hoof capsule by people who actually know how to do that. A quick glance from an owner, vet, or hoof care provider saying âthat looks okayâ simply isnât good enough anymore.
Horses arenât being lost because of grass or sugar, theyâre being lost because of rotation, pe*******on, and osteonecrosis, all of which stem from HCD, not diet. Yet the world has been conditioned to fear âlaminitisâ rather than question the hoof care practices that actually cause these outcomes.
If we keep calling every foot with even a slightly incorrect P3 position "laminitis" - eg. higher palmar angles than natural ground-parallel, with or without visible separation on x-ray - then we will never truly understand whatâs happening. Those subtle positional changes are early signs of imbalance, not metabolic disease.
Until we start measuring, tracking, and interpreting the hoof capsule correctly, the myth of âdietary laminitisâ will keep distracting us from the real, fixable cause: hoof capsule divergence (HCD).
And when we fix that - we can tell you that everyone will stop freaking out about "that dreadful disease laminitis" because horses will stop losing their lives and being put down. They will survive. Isn't that what we all want?
---------------------------
I will do a full "how did we get into this mess?" article, regards why academic research pivoted to looking at the blood and away from the hoof, in the next few days. That will be another long one.
HM.
If you are still confused by this and have a horse with rotation, pe*******on and/or osteonecrosis, please join our free rehab group and start learning about balance: The Phoenix Way: Path 2 Hoof Health
And... watch the hundred plus hours of free videos here: https://www.youtube.com/