Truly Organic Bake Shop

Truly Organic Bake Shop Home Baker - Organic Ingredients - No Seed Oils - Non GMO - Grassfed - Pastured - Unbleached - Allergen Friendly Available - Always From Scratch (No Box Mixes)

My name is Darra and I believe what we eat truly impacts our health and well-being. I love to bake and wanted to be able to provide baked goods with only the best organic ingredients. Organic unbleached flour, pastured organic eggs, grass-fed dairy, etc and I will never use seed oils. I can accommodate allergens, but please note I am not a dedicated gluten-free home. I do have a regular job as well, so availability is limited. Organic ingredients do cost more, so my prices will reflect that.

Gluten Free Lemon Cake with Lemon ButtercreamI was asked to donate a cake for Woodbrook Elementary’s PTO fundraiser in C...
02/01/2026

Gluten Free Lemon Cake with Lemon Buttercream

I was asked to donate a cake for Woodbrook Elementary’s PTO fundraiser in Carmel that took place yesterday. This is a three 8” layer gluten free lemon cake frosted with lemon buttercream.

Happy 15th Birthday to Kendall!!!1 dozen gluten free chocolate cupcakes with vanilla buttercream made purple with natura...
02/01/2026

Happy 15th Birthday to Kendall!!!

1 dozen gluten free chocolate cupcakes with vanilla buttercream made purple with natural dyes.

I’m making a couple of cakes for the Outfitters Gala charity event in February. I want to add some cool snowflake topper...
01/27/2026

I’m making a couple of cakes for the Outfitters Gala charity event in February. I want to add some cool snowflake toppers and just haven’t found anything I love on Etsy or Amazon. I would love to get something locally if anyone is great with a cricut or knows someone that does stuff like this.

Picture is NOT my cake, just an example of what I’m looking for.

Anyone gluten free want these? They expire on 1/30 and I hate to see them go to waste. They are dairy free as well.
01/23/2026

Anyone gluten free want these? They expire on 1/30 and I hate to see them go to waste. They are dairy free as well.

Happy Birthday to Jenna!!!Half dozen cupcakes - 3 strawberry filled lemon cupcakes with lemon buttercream. 3 vanilla cup...
01/22/2026

Happy Birthday to Jenna!!!

Half dozen cupcakes - 3 strawberry filled lemon cupcakes with lemon buttercream. 3 vanilla cupcakes with vanilla frosting.

Happy 7th Birthday to Harper!Harper’s cake is two 6” layers…one gf/df vanilla and one gf/df chocolate. Frosted with natu...
01/19/2026

Happy 7th Birthday to Harper!

Harper’s cake is two 6” layers…one gf/df vanilla and one gf/df chocolate. Frosted with naturally dyed purple dairy free vanilla frosting. Decorated with unicorn sprinkles.

My first piñata cake and it was a gender reveal! It was so much fun to make and I hope to make more in the future. I can...
01/18/2026

My first piñata cake and it was a gender reveal! It was so much fun to make and I hope to make more in the future.

I cannot take credit for the outside of these cakes, as the customer did the fondant work. It was her first time ever using fondant and she did an incredible job! Seriously blown away by how the cakes turned out. Stacy you nailed it!

The piñata cake is three 8” layers of vanilla cake filled with blue .snacks milk chocolate gems and blue chocolate melts. Frosted with vanilla buttercream.

The 2nd cake was three 6” layers of gluten free cake. The bottom and top are vanilla and middle layer chocolate. Frosted with vanilla buttercream.

Happy 40th Birthday to Suzane! Gluten Free Strawberry Lemon CakeTwo 6” layers of gluten free lemon cake, filled with str...
01/16/2026

Happy 40th Birthday to Suzane!

Gluten Free Strawberry Lemon Cake

Two 6” layers of gluten free lemon cake, filled with strawberry filling, then surrounded with strawberry and lemon buttercream.

1 dozen gluten free chocolate cupcakes with chocolate buttercream.

Happy 2nd Birthday to Parker!!!1 dozen gluten & dairy free vanilla cupcakes with naturally dyed dairy free vanilla frost...
01/16/2026

Happy 2nd Birthday to Parker!!!

1 dozen gluten & dairy free vanilla cupcakes with naturally dyed dairy free vanilla frosting. Blue, red, green & yellow for a “Toy Story” birthday party. So fun!

Would anyone be interested in a two layer 6” gluten free cookies and cream cake with cream cheese frosting like this one...
01/10/2026

Would anyone be interested in a two layer 6” gluten free cookies and cream cake with cream cheese frosting like this one pictured ? I could have it ready anytime you need it, preferably withon this next week. Send me a message if so.

Happy Birthday to Emily!!!!1 dozen gf/df vanilla cupcakes with DF vanilla frostingOne of the best parts of this home bak...
01/10/2026

Happy Birthday to Emily!!!!

1 dozen gf/df vanilla cupcakes with DF vanilla frosting

One of the best parts of this home bakery is meeting all of you and the friendships that have developed. Emily is one of those friendships I’m so grateful for!

Happy 5th Birthday to Zeke and Happy 3rd Birthday to Ezra!!!Paw Patrol Cake!Three 8” layers of chocolate cake and froste...
01/09/2026

Happy 5th Birthday to Zeke and Happy 3rd Birthday to Ezra!!!

Paw Patrol Cake!

Three 8” layers of chocolate cake and frosted with naturally dyed vanilla buttercream.

Address

Pendleton, IN

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Truly Organic Bake Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Practice

Send a message to Truly Organic Bake Shop:

Shortcuts

Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on LinkedIn
Share on Pinterest Share on Reddit Share via Email
Share on WhatsApp Share on Instagram Share on Telegram