12/03/2025
Do You Really Need That Protein Shake? Let's Have an Honest Conversation 💪
The short answer? It depends—and here's why that matters. As a nutrition coach & personal trainer, I'm not big on supplements unless they're backed by blood work and we've maximized what we can achieve through whole foods first.
Yet one of the most common questions new clients ask me is: "What protein shake should I be drinking?"
My response? "Why do you think you need one?"
The answers are generally the same:
"I always used them before"
"Everyone says you're supposed to"
"My last coach required it"
Let's figure it out 🤔
The Real Question: Are You Actually Struggling to Hit Your Protein Goals?
If NO: You probably don't need a shake. Your whole food intake is doing the job. If you want convenience: Protein shakes can be a solid on-the-go option—especially when they keep you out of the drive-thru.
If YES: You're genuinely struggling to consume enough protein through food alone, or your schedule makes it nearly impossible—then a quality protein powder might complement your nutrition plan.
⚠️ Important Boundaries: I never want protein shakes becoming a dietary crutch where you're relying on them for multiple "meals" daily. Whole foods should always be your foundation. But here's the catch: You can't determine if you need supplementation if you don't know your current intake. This is exactly why tracking protein is a cornerstone of my coaching protocol.
📊 The Numbers Game: As a very general starting point, we typically aim for 1 gram of protein per pound of lean body mass. The reality? Most people aren't even close to their optimal range. If you discover you need 150g daily but you're only hitting 30g, that's a significant gap that requires strategic planning—not just throwing a shake at the problem.
🎯 The Bottom Line: There's no one-size-fits-all approach here. We need to find YOUR optimal protein range based on your unique goals, lifestyle, and preferences.
Your turn: How's your protein intake looking? Are you hitting your targets, or feeling completely lost in the numbers? Drop a comment below.