01/24/2026
I had an interesting advance directive conversation over the holidays. I know,
I know…who talks about these things at family gatherings!
A family member suddenly, and seemingly stressed, said “I need to contact our attorney about changing our living will.”
Of course my head turned and my ears perked up. I asked her why the urgency.
She said “I don’t want to be an organ donor. I’m afraid.”
Now, organ donation is a wonderful gift, and I find that people seem to be slightly polarized here. Either they feel strongly for or against being a donor.
I am not here to debate the value of being an organ donor; I have seen many patients who have been recipients of a life-saving organ gift. However, if someone feels strongly about their medical wishes, that is personal and commendable. It is also critical that they put it in writing in the form of an advance directive so that their wishes are known.
I encouraged this family member to make the update to her documents to reflect her strong opinion.
Of note, the fact that she had this conversation with the family is probably the most important part of the process. We heard the passion in her voice and her medical wishes were clear. There was no confusion for me: she does not want to be an organ donor and now I am clear on that.
To me, this is an example of a “pearl” that comes out of these conversations. People use tone, words, and body language to express strong and memorable opinions.
The written advance directive is the cherry on top!
The 15 minute conversation that can prevent a lifetime of guilt By Eleanor Tanno, M.D. When someone is critically ill and in the hospital, physicians usually first consult their family members about the type of medical care to provide. If a spouse is not available, adult children are typically the n...