22/12/2025
When Catholics are discerning between two genuinely good choices, the Church teaches that discernment is less about finding a “hidden right answer” and more about freely choosing the good that best leads us to love God and others more. Here is how Catholics are encouraged to discern:
First, pray for interior freedom. Catholics ask the Holy Spirit for indifference in the Ignatian sense—not apathy, but freedom from selfish attachments, fear, or pride—so that the decision is guided by love rather than anxiety or pressure.
Second, examine intentions and fruits. Both options may be morally good, so the question becomes: Which choice better helps me grow in faith, hope, and charity? Which leads to greater service, peace, and responsibility? Jesus teaches, “By their fruits you will know them” (Mt 7:16).
Third, listen to consolation and desolation. Drawing from St. Ignatius of Loyola, Catholics reflect on which option brings deeper peace, joy, and closeness to God (consolation), and which brings persistent unrest or spiritual heaviness (desolation), while remembering that emotions must be weighed with reason.
Fourth, use reason and Church wisdom. Discernment involves practical reflection: circumstances, duties to family and community, long-term consequences, and guidance from Scripture, Church teaching, and trusted spiritual mentors.
Finally, decide in faith and entrust the outcome to God. When both choices are good, the Church affirms that God allows genuine freedom. Once a decision is made, Catholics are called to move forward with confidence, trusting that God will work through a sincere and prayerful choice (Rom 8:28).
In short, Catholics discern between two good choices by praying, reflecting on fruits, seeking peace and wisdom, and trusting God’s grace—knowing that choosing the good in love is already a way of following God’s will.
+++
Prayer for Discernment
Lord God, as I stand before two good paths, quiet my heart and free me from fear. Send Your Holy Spirit to guide my thoughts, purify my intentions, and lead me to choose what brings greater love, deeper peace, and faithful service to You and others. I trust that in choosing the good, I walk in Your will.
Amen. 💛