29/11/2025
Really interesting video about ECT (Electroconvulsive Therapy).
For those on this platform:
Did you know, ECT is highly prevalent as a 'treatment' still - that is anaesthetising a person and relaxing muscles before sending electrical currents into a person's brain?
Did you know about the far reaching impacts and harms reported?
Did you know that the impacts and harms are often played down?
Did you know that there is no research based placebo controlled evidence since 1985 to support claims of the benefit of ECT in depression?
(Read et al, 2025) https://lnkd.in/g8Yfjg56
Recently a team of researchers from the UK have published 5 papers from their recent international survey of people who have experienced ECT. The papers have been published in peer reviewed journals and paint a stark picture regarding lack of efficacy and increased knowledge on the harms caused.
The current narrative and associated propaganda in health services that deliver ECT do not include current evidence. People are forced to have ECT under the mental health act legislation. A good starting place on modern evidence is here: https://lnkd.in/g8Yfjg56
It really is time for an honest review in Australia and perhaps consider ceasing ECT until an evidence based and understanding of harm has been conducted.
From the video below, talking about the origins of ECT!
"In the 1930s, there was a theory that if you had schizophrenia, which is what ECT was introduced for, used mostly for depression now, but it was introduced for schizophrenia.
If you had schizophrenia, you couldn't have epilepsy, it was mutually exclusive. There's a lot of theories like that around. There was no truth to it,
but it was written in medical journals that if you had one, you couldn't have the other.
So therefore, they thought the cure for schizophrenia would be to cause epilepsy. At the same time, some people were trying to cure epilepsy
by injecting the blood of people diagnosed with schizophrenia into people with epilepsy. It was completely bonkers, but it was well-intentioned like
most medical theories are. And then the task became, how do we cause seizures?
And they tried many different things like insulin coma, so pumping up high levels of insulin into people until they went into a coma.
Eventually, they found that electricity would do the job, would cause convulsions, and they found that out by accident.
Two psychiatrists in Italy happened to see at a slaughterhouse pigs being
given electricity to numb them before they were killed, and they would saw
them go into a sort of convulsion. So they thought they tried it on a human being. And that's the history of ECT. Looking back, it's obviously a ridiculous
theory. And the bizarre thing is that we're still doing it 80 years later."
Thank you John Read Lucy Johnstone and other team members for your incredible and inpactful work on ECT.
https://youtu.be/bGxOtZ4dEKE
In this episode, I'm talking with professor John Read (University of East London) about the evidence base and the consequences of ECT .This is the first epis...