05/12/2025
The Silver Report
Victorian Treasurer Jaclyn Symes has released (4/12/2025) the final report from Independent Reviewer Helen Silver AO — the former top bureaucrat tasked with streamlining Victoria's public sector by identifying inefficiencies and consolidating government entities - as well as the government's response.
ABC News https://tinyurl.com/48eevdcx
Full 154 page Report: https://tinyurl.com/rd4eanev
Victorian Govt response: https://www.vic.gov.au/vps-review
What Matters Most summaries: https://tinyurl.com/zn6e9wts
The Report is comprehensive within the the Review’s Terms of Reference that excluded integrity bodies and Parliament and other bodies not within scope due to their independent functions.
Frontline workers were considered outside the scope of the Review and thus the Review did not consider schools, hospitals, health services and the police. Individual courts, local government and departments were also excluded. Captured within scope were 90+advisory committees.
The Department of Health is used as a case study - with Victorian health spending increasing over the past 10 years, with real per capita state health expenditure increasing by 39 per cent in Victoria since 2014-15 and contrasted at $4200 in 2023-24 with NSW at $3600.
The Silver Review covers several related issues with reform proposals, including an increased role for preventive health measures, greater use of digital systems, delivery of care closer to home, and transitioning out of areas of Commonwealth responsibilities (p 41).
The Review recommended the Health Complaints Commissioner role be absorbed into Safer Care Victoria so as to realise operational efficiencies and reduce administrative costs.
Another merger proposal was to merge human rights offices and commissioners within the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission (VEOHRC), bringing together the Commissioner for LGBTIQA+ Communities, Commission for Gender Equality in the Public Sector, Commission for Children and Young People, the Victorian Multicultural Commission and the Office of the Public Advocate within VEOHRC. This initiative is intended to leverages expertise, increase administrative efficiency and provide a one-door approach to human rights services with VEOHRC to become a centre for excellence for human rights.
The Review recommends streamlining the regulatory system to a smaller number of larger, focused regulators that could address common issues and concentrate on core regulatory activities. However, it is noted that too large regulators tend to lose efficiency, subject matter expertise and focus on the sectors they regulate, and knowledge of the sector dynamics and the priority risks of harm.
AHCRA reiterates that patient (community) safety and health practitioner regulation are of paramount importance and a fundamental role of government. www.pc.gov.au/inquiries/current/quality-care
Effective implementation of the various merger proposals is crucial and it is absolutely vital that the health-related input provided by advocacy groups is retained. Some of the strongest reactions and objections to the Review proposals have been those relating to the news that VicHealth will close as a standalone agency and be absorbed into the State Department of Health.
https://www.croakey.org/shock-and-alarm-greet-news-about.../
Among the insights offered by the Review was that Victoria should strengthen its approach to oversee and manage entities (p 149). It should implement best practice governance structures, enhance visibility and monitoring through data, conduct first-principles necessity reviews, and sunset entities by default.
The Victorian Secretaries’ Board will oversee implementation and its monitoring role will be supported by the Department of Premier and Cabinet and the Department of Treasury and Finance. https://tinyurl.com/3rpd7af3