02/10/2025
📘 A Clinician's Guide to Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex (TFCC) Tears: Assessment and Management
◼️ The Triangular Fibrocartilage Complex (TFCC) tear is one of the most common causes of ulnar-sided wrist pain and disability, frequently presenting in physiotherapy clinics
◼️ A thorough understanding of the TFCC's intricate anatomy, biomechanics, and the evidence-based management pathways is essential for effective patient care
◼️ This post provides a detailed overview for clinicians, covering assessment, classification, and management strategies based on current evidence
🦴 Anatomy and Biomechanics: The Keystone of the Ulnar Wrist
◼️ The TFCC is a robust ligamentous structure with two primary functions: it stabilizes the distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) and acts as a shock absorber between the ulnar head and the carpus
Key Anatomical Components:
◼️ The central component is the triangular fibrocartilage (articular disk)
◼️ Supported by volar and dorsal radioulnar ligaments, the volar ulnotriquetral and ulnolunate ligaments, the ulnar collateral ligament, and the extensor carpi ulnaris (ECU) tendon sheath
◼️ The TFCC attaches radially to the distal radius, a relatively avascular zone with poor healing potential
◼️ It attaches ulnarly to both the ulnar fovea (proximal lamina) and the ulnar styloid (distal lamina). This peripheral region is well-vascularized, giving it good healing potential
Biomechanics and Ulnar Variance:
◼️ The TFCC is a key static stabilizer of the DRUJ, with dynamic stability contributed by the ECU and pronator quadratus muscles
◼️ Load transmission across the wrist is heavily influenced by ulnar variance—the relative length of the ulna to the radius
◼️ With neutral ulnar variance, the ulnocarpal joint transmits about 18% of the axial load
◼️ With a 2.5 mm positive ulnar variance, this load increases to 42%, making the thinner TFCC more prone to degenerative tears
◼️ With a 2.5 mm negative ulnar variance, the load decreases to just 4.3%
🩺 Etiology and Classification
◼️ TFCC tears can be traumatic (acute) or degenerative (chronic)
Traumatic Tears (Palmer Type 1):
◼️ Often caused by a fall onto an outstretched hand (FOOSH), a violent forearm twist, or axial loading
◼️ Classified by the location of the tear (central, radial, or ulnar avulsion)
Degenerative Tears (Palmer Type 2):
◼️ Result from chronic overload, often associated with ulnocarpal impaction syndrome and positive ulnar variance
◼️ Graded by the severity of wear, from chondromalacia to full perforation and arthritis
Treatment-Oriented Classification:
◼️ Atzei, Luchetti, and Garagnani further refine Palmer 1B tears based on tear repairability and DRUJ stability, guiding surgical decision-making
🧾 Clinical Assessment: From History to Provocative Testing
◼️ A definitive diagnosis relies on a combination of thorough history, physical examination, and imaging
Subjective Assessment:
◼️ Patients typically report ulnar-sided wrist pain, sometimes with clicking or popping with forearm rotation, decreased grip strength, and a sensation of instability
◼️ Traumatic tears have a clear mechanism of injury
◼️ Degenerative tears often have an insidious onset
Objective Examination:
◼️ Always include comparison to the unaffected side
◼️ Observation: Look for bony asymmetry or dorsal prominence of the ulna, which can indicate DRUJ injury
◼️ Palpation: Tenderness over the fovea (between ulnar styloid, FCU tendon, and pisiform) = positive ulnar fovea sign, may indicate foveal disruption of the TFCC
◼️ Sensitivity 73-90%, specificity 8-44%
◼️ Range of Motion & Strength: Passive forearm rotation often elicits pain and mechanical symptoms, resisted rotation may reveal weakness
◼️ Provocative Maneuvers: Integral for reproducing symptoms and assessing stability
Ballottement Test: Assesses DRUJ instability by translating the ulna in volar/dorsal directions; increased translation = instability
Press Test: Patient lifts from chair using arms; focal ulnar wrist pain = positive
Grind Test: Axial compression + forearm rotation; pain/crepitus may indicate arthritis or instability. Sensitivity 90-93%, specificity 12-20%
Imaging:
◼️ Plain x-rays rule out fractures and assess ulnar variance (cannot visualize TFCC tear itself)
◼️ MRI/MRA detail soft-tissue injuries (MRA higher accuracy)
◼️ Arthroscopy = gold standard for definitive diagnosis, allows visualization and assessment of size, location, and repairability
⚕️ Management Strategies: From Conservative Care to Surgical Intervention
Conservative Management:
◼️ Initial management for most TFCC tears is non-operative
◼️ Immobilization: Splint/cast for 4-6 weeks. Resolves symptoms in about 60% of patients
◼️ Activity modification & Anti-inflammatories
◼️ Corticosteroid Injection: Considered if symptoms persist after immobilization
Surgical Management:
◼️ Indicated if conservative measures fail
◼️ Tailored to tear type, location, and chronicity
Arthroscopic Debridement: For stable, central (avascular) tears (Palmer 1A)
Arthroscopic/Open Repair: For peripheral tears in vascular zone (Palmer 1B). Includes suturing or reattaching TFCC to restore DRUJ stability
Reconstruction: For irreparable or chronic tears; tendon graft (often palmaris longus) used
Ulnocarpal Unloading Procedures: For degenerative tears with positive ulnar variance → ulnar shortening osteotomy or wafer procedure
Salvage Procedures: For severe DRUJ arthritis → Darrach, Sauve-Kapandji, or arthroplasty
🏋️ Post-Operative Rehabilitation Considerations
◼️ Following Debridement: ~2 weeks cast immobilization
◼️ Following Repair: ~6 weeks cast immobilization → progressive rehab → return to sport at 3 months
◼️ Following Reconstruction: Up to 12 weeks immobilization (long-arm cast → splints). Supervised ROM begins ~3 weeks post-op
◼️ Electroacupuncture + standard rehab after arthroscopic repair may improve hand function (DASH score)
📊 Prognosis and Key Takeaways
◼️ Prognosis depends on:
1. Vascularity: Peripheral (ulnar) portion heals well; central & radial portions avascular, poor healing
2. Chronicity: Acute tears (6 months) have poor healing
◼️ For physiotherapists: success depends on accurate diagnosis, understanding underlying pathology, knowledge of surgical procedures, and managing post-op rehab
◼️ Managing patient expectations regarding healing times and functional outcomes is paramount