01/10/2026
Stroke, heart attack, head injury, car accident, giving birth, house fires, convulsing children, facial laceration, gun shot wounds.
Some of these eventually affect us and require immediate response - any delay can cause irreparable damage.
The Traffic Plan wants to narrow roads and congest streets - slow everyone down to a crawl and impair traffic flow through intersections They state this at least 25 times in the report.
This prevents emergency vehicles from arriving at YOUR emergency.
How happy will you be that the fire truck had to stop traffic, make it back up and then try to navigate a corner such as the Swirls intersection at 4th Street SW. The traffic planners seem to say burn baby, burn.
And what does the MPC have against making a safe right hand turn onto Division Ave? They want to bring this to Riverside and other areas of the City. Why?
HOW DOES TRAFFIC CALMING AFFECT EMERGENCY VEHICLE RESPONSE TIME?
Here are some quotes from various published articles :
https://highways.dot.gov/
5.2 Emergency Services – Fire
The local fire department is generally the first responder to an emergency medical situation. The time it takes for a fire vehicle to arrive is a primary concerns along with the safety of the emergency vehicle occupants. Of all emergency services, fire departments have traditionally been the most vocal about traffic calming. Some cities explicitly discourage and even restrict certain traffic calming measures from being placed on bus routes.
1/ Traffic calming measures are designed to reduce vehicle speeds and improve safety on the roads. However, the impact on emergency vehicle response time can vary. Some studies suggest that traffic calming can lead to increased response times for emergency vehicles, particularly fire apparatus, due to their size and the need for a quick response to emergencies.
2/ The efficiency of emergency medical services (EMS), fire and police departments is increasingly compromised by traffic congestion and the reluctance of drivers to yield to emergency vehicles. A recent industry survey of 2,500 first responders showed that 49.5% of first responder agencies reported worsened response times in 2024 compared to 2023. Another 41.7% cited traffic congestion as the biggest challenge in improving response times.
3/ IFC Section 503.4.1 states that traffic calming measures placed on fire apparatus access roads "shall be prohibited unless approved by the fire code official."
4/ In Section A.5.2.18, NFPA 1141 states that prior to installation of traffic calming, the authority having jurisdiction "should work with the emergency response departments to ensure traffic calming devices can be negotiated by emergency response vehicles in a safe and timely manner without damage to those vehicles." ( The Swirls corner certainly does not allow this.)
There is a lot more info.
So what do you think? How happy will you be with the Municipal Planning people if it is your house on fire? Or your baby that must be rushed to hospital?
I agree with safety, but it must be for everyone - not just a select few.
This is my opinion.
Greg
highways.dot.gov
Federal Highway Administration
Strengthening our world-class highway system.