11/13/2019
Sleep training is a response to a major problem. The manifestation of the problem is the stress, frustration, and exhaustion of parents who have night waking babies. For many, the situation is totally unsustainable. However, the root of the major problem is not that babies are anxious night owls; it is that there is not enough support for parenting.
Babies require soothing. They need to be supported in getting to sleep. They need the vibe of a calm, attuned person to co-regulate their nervous systems within. This deep need for connection babies have is primal and evolutionary. When a parent becomes exhausted by life's demands and understandably jangled by compounded stress, it makes sense that many babies will also feel wired while tired, deepening parental suffering.
Our modern parenting culture is generally structured around the privilege of the space and things that contain us. It costs a lot to maintain the space and things we provide for our families, physically, mentally, and emotionally, never mind financially.
Babies generally do not want space and things. They want closeness and security. We ask our babies, wired for secure attachment, to express our culture's avoidant attachment style because we need our energy to maintain our space and things without enough support.
These problems are real, and require tremendous compassion.
"Fixing" the babies through sleep training is our cultural go to, though there is evidence when looking at the field of neuro-development that there can often be problems with this. What really needs fixing? Our incredible isolation as parents. Being alone at night with a baby who yowls every time you try to take a ni**le out of their mouth, or a toddler who freaks out the moment you try to put them into a crib when you know the day stretches before you in an overwhelming sea of exhaustion? No wonder people are looking for quick fixes. Parents are desperate. Chronic sleep deprivation is unhealthy and dangerous.
Imagine how much easier it would be if we lived in deeper community, where many folks occupied a kitchen happily making food together, and where there was an available set of arms or two at night to soothe a baby so parents could get sleep; a society in which parenthood was honoured, nourished, and supported, upheld as the most important role in the world.
Fostering separation is a fix. But it is a radical movement towards consistently connected community that will be the healing.
At MotherWit Doula Care we strive to create connected community. We also offer overnight family care in order to help families rest and reboot. It can be amazing how babies settle when parents have an opportunity to settle.
It takes a village to raise a child.