02/12/2026
Inside AA, debate about whether AA is religious or spiritual can be entertaining. It's about definitions, isn't it? In the USA, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that AA is a religion. The "God" or "higher power" language in AA's literature and culture is, by legal definition, "religious." And requiring AA participation as part of probation, sentencing, a continuing employment contract, courts view this as a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. Americans are free to practice religion without interference from the State, and they are protected from religion or coercion by the State to attend religious activities.
Beyond the USA and their laws, many professionals know the data about AA being effective evidience-based support for people with alcohol use disorder. AND, most intake questions for a psychologist or healthcare professional do not include, "What is your creed," or "How are you about the 'God' word?"
Is Secular AA as a referal a way to avoid the whole issue of worldviews, or being for or against a faith-based approach to recovery from addiction? Here's an article on LinkedIn - let us know what you think.
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/secular-aa-way-avoid-religiousirreligious-issues-secular-aa-e9vbc