05/06/2021
Penny Simkin, author of "The Birth Partner," conducted a study in which she asked women who attended her childbirth classes taught between 1968-1974 to send her their birth stories shortly after giving birth to their first child. Between 15 and 20 years later, she contacted these mothers again, asking them to write their birth stories as they remembered them and to rate their satisfaction with those childbirth experiences. Penny Simkin writes the following:
In comparing the two stories from each person, I was astounded at how clearly they remembered their birth experiences and how consistent they were with their original stories, despite the intervening years! Everyone vividly remembered specific things said and done to them. Many could quote the exact words! Some actually wept as they recalled some of these things--either with joy over the kindness and care they received or with sadness and anger over being treated disrespectfully or thoughtlessly. Briefly, those who felt they had been well cared for by the professional staff reported the highest satisfaction, even if the labors had been long or complicated. Those who felt they had been disrespected or ignored felt the least satisfaction. Also, those who reported a great sense of accomplishment in giving birth were the most satisfied. They felt they had been in control and that the birth experience had been good for their self-esteem. The less satisfied women did not have these positive feelings.
I learned from that study that birthing persons need and appreciate loving, familiar people to stay with them, help them, and share the birth--one of life's most meaningful moments. The kind of professional care and emotional support they receive during labour largely influences how they look back on the birth experience--with satisfaction and fulfillment or with disappointment, sadness, and anger. I realized, in this age of high-tech, high-pressure obstetrics, it is unreasonable to expect busy nurses, doctors, and even hospital based midwives to provide continuous individualized emotional and physical comfort throughout labor and birth.
I have always been guided by the question, "how will they remember this?"