14/08/2022
Seasonal Malaria Chemoprevention (SMC), which combines amodiaquine (AQ) with sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP), is an effective and promising strategy, recommended by WHO, for controlling malaria morbidity and mortality in areas of intense seasonal transmission. Despite the effectiveness of this strategy, a number of controversies regarding the impact of the development of malaria-specific immunity and challenges of the strategy in the context of increasing and expanding antimalarial drugs resistance but also the limited coverage of the SMC in children make the relevance of the SMC questionable, especially in view of the financial and logistical investments. Indeed, the number of malaria cases in the target group, children under 5 years old, has increased while the implementation of SMC is been extended in several African countries. This ambivalence of the SMC strategy, the increase in the prevalence of malaria cases suggests the need to evaluate the SMC and understand some of the factors that may hinder the success of this strategy in the implementation areas. The present review discusses the impact of the SMC on malaria morbidity, parasite resistance to antimalarial drugs, molecular and the immunity affecting the incidence of malaria in children. This approach will contribute to improving the malaria control strategy in highly seasonal transmission areas where the SMC is implemented.
Keywords: seasonal malaria chemoprevention, immunity, resistance, sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine, amodiaquine
Malaria is still a leading cause of morbidity and mortality despite all the efforts made to control the disease. Over 80% of malaria cases and 90% of malaria deaths occur in Africa and mainly in children.1 Although the incidence of malaria is declining in many parts of sub-Saharan Africa, it remains an important public health problem, especially in risk groups such as infants, children, and pregnant women. In this region of Africa, most of the malaria cases and deaths occur during or immediately after the rainy season (approximately from July to October) and children below 5 years of age are at the greatest risk; world malaria report 2021 data indicate that 60–75% in 2009–2017 still occurred in children aged under 5 years.1 In order to strengthen the fight against malaria in children, a new preventive strategy was developed and recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO) in 2012 following a report of the Technical Expert Group (TEG) of Preventive Chemotherapy. Seasonal Malaria Chemoprevention (SMC), previously referred to as Intermittent Preventive Treatment in children (IPTc), is defined as the intermittent administration of full treatment courses of an antimalarial drug to children during the peak of the malaria transmission season with the aim of preventing malaria-associated mortality and morbidity2 by a malaria prevention strategy in children living in the Sahel sub-regions of Africa.3,4 The Sahel stretches from Senegal on the Atlantic coast, through parts of Mauritania, Mali, Burkina Faso, Niger, Nigeria, Chad, and Sudan, to Eritrea on the Red Sea coast. According to the WHO policy recommendation, SMC involves the repeated administration of therapeutic doses of Sulfadoxine-Pyrimethamine (SP) and Amodiaquine (AQ) drugs at monthly intervals during the malaria transmission period in areas where malaria is endemic and seasonal.5–7 SP+AQ is a non-artemisinin combination treatment.
Mali was one of the first countries in the Sahel region to implement SMC in 2012, which has now been gradually rolled out to cover the entire country.8 As of 2020, 13 countries have adopted SMC (Benin, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Chad, Gambia, Ghana, Guinea, Guinea Bissau, Mali, Niger, Nigeria, Senegal, and Togo) at different scales of implementation.9 Several studies in Africa have shown that this intervention is cost-effective, safe, and feasible for the prevention of malaria among children in areas with highly seasonal malaria transmission.10,11 The number of children reached with at least one dose of SMC has increased steadily from nearly 0.2 million in 2012 to about 33.5 million in 2020 in 13 countries in the African Sahel.1
Methodology
We considered as relevant all articles published online in PubMed by using the search terms “SMC” or “Seasonal malaria chemoprevention”. As a precursor term of the SMC strategy, we have also included the term “intermittent preventive treatment in children” or “IPTc” in our search. We concluded the literature research on April 5, 2022. Finally, we considered the studies eligible only if they met the following inclusion criteria: a) the articles were written in English and published by April 5, 2022, b) the study was carried out in Sahelian Africa region participants (except those used to discuss the review), and c) Sulfadoxine-Pyrimethamine and Amodiaquine, Dihydroartemisinin-Piperaquine should be used as antimalarial drugs.
The manuscripts with only abstracts available were excluded as we could not access the full text. We then reviewed the following: deployment and implementation progression, the impact of SMC on the prevalence of malaria cases in high-risk individuals, the factors affecting the effectiveness of the Seasonal Malaria Chemoprevention, and the interaction of the SMC with malaria immunity and the coverage of the SMC.
Results and Discussions
Specificity and Outcomes of the Selected Studies for Review
From the PubMed search using the specific terms mentioned above, 249 articles were found and 185 studies met the inclusion criteria, as presented in
Paper mining flowchart. *Others West Africa include Gambia, Nigeria, Ghana, Côte D’Ivoire, Guinea, Chad, and Mauritania.
Abbreviations: SMC, Seasonal Malaria Chemoprevention; IPTc, Intermittent Preventive Treatment in Children.
Although we sought out the bulk of articles on SMC with full texts, the reality of our review focused primarily on data collected in the Sahelian part of Africa where the SMC is the WHO recommendation. Of course, we have used some data from Nigeria and Ghana, parts of which have a seasonal malaria transmission pattern. We believe that focusing the review on articles published on studies conducted in Burkina Faso, Mali, Niger, and Senegal will essentially help to better show the effect of SMC on malaria morbidity, resistant genotypes, or immunity that we are looking for because at the moment the WHO requirements and recommendations are focused in this area.
The published studies on Seasonal Malaria Chemoprevention were predominantly conducted in West Africa (168/185, 90.8%). Three countries in the Sahelian regions (Senegal, Mali, and Burkina Faso) account for more than 80% (136/166) of the studies conducted in the West African region (Figure 2). The first pilot studies on the intermittent prevention treatment in children were carried out in Senegal in 2006,12 and Mali13 and Burkina Faso14 started this evaluation in 2008 as a multi-center study. Looking at the report from WHO,3 it is important to note that the results of the evaluations in Burkina Faso, Mali, and Senegal were extremely decisive in WHO’s decision to adopt this preventive strategy called SMC as one of the strategies that can contribute significantly to the reduction of malaria morbidity and mortality in the area where malaria transmission is seasonal. Many articles reflect the same topics. Then, to avoid redundancy many are not included in the list of author references.
Three countries accounting for more than 80% of the SMC studies in West Africa.
SMC Deployment and Implementation in Sub-Saharan Africa
The implementation of SMC in Sahelian countries has been gradual from a pilot phase in the various countries to a full-scale phase to the entire population of concerned countries. By organizing the implementation in this way, the actors learn from the lessons and failures and then improve the progress. This implementation process has been strongly supported by committed organizations (Medicines for Malaria Venture, Malaria Consortium, UNICEF, Global Fund, UNITAID, WHO, World Bank, PMI) alongside National Malaria Control Programs in Sub-Saharan Africa. This synergy remains today a winning combination in the implementation of SMC in Sub-Saharan Africa. Indeed, by bringing in their experience in program management, by building bridges between the different countries implementing this strategy and bringing additional financial and logistical resources, the scale up of SMC has been remarkable to reach the majority of eligible children in the Sahelian countries. Countries like Burkina Faso took about 6 years (2014 to 2019) to cover the country's entire health districts (about 70 health districts) with the support from the Malaria Consortium, USAID, PMI, Unitaid, Global Fund, and World Bank
Example of Seasonal Malaria Chemoprevention deployment and coverage in Burkina Faso (unpublished data from Malaria Consortium).
It is important that the organizational approach (3 days dose administration for each child during four cycles) is well respected by the parties implementing the strategy by putting in place procedures to better monitor planned activities. Although the WHO policy recommendation is for four monthly cycles, countries can set their own policies according to the local context. In that context five cycles are now implemented in several countries, including Burkina Faso (across the southern half of the country), in areas where the peak of transmission season is slightly longer. But the core of the SMC strategy still remains the 4 months of implementation. One of the expansion approaches of the SMC also concerns the targeted ages, with the option to extend above 5 years. There are some studies that have focused on older ages,15–19 with arguments related to the shift of the transmission curve in the tranche from 5 to 10 years. Senegal is a pilot country in extending the age target from 5 to 10 years.15,19 Confirmation of the interest of the extension of the age range is strongly awaited to further enlighten the scientific community on the cost-benefit of this extension. In addition, the potential benefit of expanding the age group eligible for preventive treatment needs to be weighed against its potential risks, including development of drug resistance and/or the risk of hindering acquisition or maintenance of immunity. However, the WHO Technical Advisory Committee felt that any adjustment should be tailored to the needs of each country and its context. This is especially important as countries should be supported to develop or revisit their strategies for greater effectiveness.
Impact of SMC on the Prevalence of Malaria Cases in High-Risk Individuals
Pilot Studies as a Proof of Concept of the SMC Strategies
To confirm SMC as a strategy that can positively influence the prevalence or incidence of malaria in a population of children at risk of malaria, pilot studies were conducted mainly in Burkina Faso, Mali, and Senegal, under the known names of intermittent preventive treatment in children. These studies, considered to be the “ancestors” of the SMC, involved more than 3,000 children in each of these countries. The results generated from those studies2,15,16,20 allowed WHO to recommend the strategy for scaling up in the Sahel while the following should be noted.
Indeed, results from studies in Senegal from Cissé et al's12 study showed a malaria reduction incidence of 86% among children who received seasonal intermittent preventive treatment. The same trends of malaria incidence rate reduction were confirmed in a case-control study in Mali with 3.2 episodes in the treatment group vs 5.8 episodes in the control group, with age-adjusted Protective Efficacy (PE) of 42.5% (95% CI=28.6–53.8%).13
A parallel study was conducted during the same period in Burkina Faso. Malaria incidence defined as fever or history of fever with parasitaemia ≥5,000/µL, assessed during this study, was estimated at 2.88 (95% CI=2.70–3.06) per child in the control arm versus 0.87 (95% CI=0.78–0.97) in the intervention arm with a protective efficacy (PE) of 70% (95% CI=66–74%) (p