02/03/2023
Another thought for the day after another 'Research Battle' I have had in recent days!! What do you all consider 'WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE' to mean? The situation I have faced is this........ a person I have found has plenty of records to back up when and where she was born, who her parents were, who she married and so on. Yet 1 record (a marriage certificate in my possession) gives a different name for her father to that which is already in place!
Do you think 1 record can 'top trump' the other 30 or so that we have access to? OR does weight of evidence come into play? I believe errors can be made on certificates and censuses and if not careful we can chase down blind alleys after red herrings. Common sense should prevail and let the evidence be the decider :)