05/12/2025
This is one for the psychologists and philosophers among you. Not so long ago I had a curious discussion with a practitioner regarding his methodology about how to get into postures. The technique involved what he called “fantasy” whereby one would imagine or “fantasise” the completion of the asana. If we just set aside the fundamental fact that practice isn’t about any kind of completion its not difficult to see holes in this method. Firstly, taking anywhere from 15-20 seconds to get into the pose involves a whole lot of strain and struggle, while the rest of class are already wrapping up their 5th breath in the asana and flying through with lightness and energy
If we are to accept the validity of this method, could we not also question that the entire concept could be a “fantasy” itself? This raises the whole topic of role of ‘mind’ in the practice. If we go along with this line of thinking we very quickly end up in a maze of ever decreasing (or increasing!) circles of mind-layers whereby it is simply impossible to actually ever get to the bottom. And just when we think we have got to the bottom of it, there could always potentially be yet another layer, or mind-packet that contains all prior notions. It is never-ending, and eternally unresolved
This is why the correct method of ashtanga yoga practice sufficiently annihilates any of these concepts via the crucible of fire and breath. It doesn’t side-step the issue. It simply exposes the redundancy of any type of thinking, conceptualising, or mind-stuff with respect to any truly effective ashtanga yoga practice. Nancy Gilgoff often said “you jump into the pose quickly with no hesitation BEFORE the mind has chance to get in.” Plain and simple. I’ve never heard anyone else repeat this, other than her direct students. This is not a place for mindfulness, or awareness. It is mindless, and infinitely humbling
It might seem implausible that one can practice yoga without being involved in it on some mind-level. But some day, usually unannounced, the realisation may arise “oh…. this is all just… happening.”