16/02/2026
"Women, and especially mothers, are often framed as anxious, emotional, uninformed, or easily misled when they want to respond to their babies and keep them close at night. When mothers want to do the most natural thing in the world, which is to respond to their babies and keep them close, they are often infantilized and framed as silly, uninformed, or as women who are victimizing themselves. In that kind of framing, mothers who practice responsive caregiving at night can end up being perceived as overly emotional or ignorant, even when what they’re doing is a very deliberate and biologically normal way of caring for an infant.
"When decisions are framed this way, mothers begin doubting themselves and their instincts, looking to 'experts' to tell them how to parent. Instead of asking whether an approach actually fits their baby, they wonder if they’re being irrational, weak, or 'too attached.'
"So, no, Emily, it’s not that we are scared of sleep training. It’s that we know our babies and have chosen to lean into our intuition that tells us to respond to them. It’s because responsiveness creates order and peace in our homes, where sleep training would feel chaotic and stressful. That choice is usually made with education, wisdom, reason, and discernment."
Emily Oster recently published an article called “Why Is Everyone Afraid of Sleep Training?” The intention of the piece is pretty clear: to reassure parents that sleep training is supported by evidence, and that concerns about harm are largely unfounded and generally "fear mongering". While some...