03/05/2026
Reflect Orbital:
My name is _______________________ and I am writing from ________________________________. If approved, they would alter the night sky as we know it, with impacts that would be increasingly difficult, if not impossible, to reverse.
The proposal from Reflect Orbital, which plans to deploy satellites fitted with in-space mirrors to beam reflected sunlight back to Earth at night. Marketed as “sunlight on demand,” the company says the system could extend daylight for solar farms or be sold to cities to illuminate streets at brightness levels exceeding three times that of the full moon is a health and ecological disaster.
Such illumination would introduce an entirely new source of artificial light at night, with far-reaching consequences, including disruption to wildlife and ecosystems that depend on natural cycles of light and dark, as well as serious public safety concerns.
Artificial light, even the moon/or sun’s light during off times has a significant impact on human health:
Artificial light causes significant health concerns by disrupting the body's circadian rhythm and melatonin production, leading to sleep disorders, metabolic issues (diabetes, obesity), cardiovascular disease, and increased risk of certain cancers. Chronic, intense exposure can also cause retinal damage and accelerate aging. (NIH)
• Circadian Rhythm & Sleep Disruption: Exposure to artificial light at night inhibits melatonin, the hormone regulating sleep. This causes poor sleep quality, insomnia, and delayed sleep phase syndrome.
• Cardiovascular Risks: Increased nighttime light exposure is associated with higher blood vessel inflammation and a greater risk of heart disease.
• Metabolic Disorders: Nighttime light exposure increases insulin resistance, raising the risk of type 2 diabetes and obesity.
• Cancer Risk: Light at night is linked to an increased risk of breast cancer.
• Eye Health: Intense, short-wavelength blue light (common in LEDs) can damage the retina and cause age-related macular degeneration (AMD).
• Mental Health: Exposure to bright,, artificial, or outdoor light at night is linked to depression, mood disorders, and, in adolescents, potential mental health impacts.
Forced daylight could easily be likened to torture. Forced exposure to light is a recognized form of torture. This can involve either forced solar gazing (FSG) or the use of intense artificial light in detention settings, often as a component of psychological or "no-touch" torture methods. (NIH)
Methods and Techniques
Forced exposure to light is often used in combination with other abusive techniques to break a prisoner's mind and body. (UC Berkeley Law)
• Forced Solar Gazing (FSG): Victims are forced to stare directly at the midday sun for extended periods, such as half an hour or more, often repeatedly over successive days. Refusal to comply is met with beatings or other physical abuse. This can cause solar retinopathy, which may lead to permanent retinal changes and impaired vision.
• Constant Artificial Light: Detainees may be held in cells with bright lights on 24 hours a day to disorient them and deprive them of a sense of time. This is frequently used with sleep deprivation, noise bombardment, and temperature manipulation to maximize distress. (NIH)
Physical and Psychological Effects
Forced exposure to light is considered highly destructive to a person's health and psyche. (UC Berkeley Law)
• Physical Effects: The primary physical effect of FSG is solar retinopathy, which damages the retina. Other effects may be linked to the combined use of other torturous methods, such as physical injury from beatings for non-compliance.
• Psychological Effects: Survivors of light exposure torture suffer serious psychological conditions, with all individuals in one case study being diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Other symptoms include depression, anxiety, fear of blindness, and dissociative behaviors, which can make clinical assessment difficult and risk re-traumatization during standard medical examinations using bright lights. The deliberate assault on the mind can be more destructive than purely physical assaults. (NIH)
Legal and Ethical Status
Human rights organizations such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watchdocument cases involving forced light exposure as torture or cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment. While some techniques were once miscategorized as "torture lite" or "enhanced interrogation techniques" by some authorities, expert consensus and numerous studies confirm their severe and long-lasting impacts, classing them unequivocally as torture. The United Nations Convention Against Torture absolutely prohibits such acts. (HowStuffWorks)
Artificial light at night (ALAN), even the moon/or sun’s light during off times, severely disrupts ecosystems by:
• confusing wildlife, altering nocturnal habitats, and suppressing melatonin production, which regulates sleep and biological rhythms in animals and plants. It triggers cascading effects: causing fatal bird collisions, disrupting migratory paths, fatal disorientation for sea turtles, and massive insect population declines. (DarkSky International)
Key Ecosystem Impacts:
• Nocturnal Animals & Predators: Light creates "night-into-day" conditions, disrupting foraging, mating, and predator-prey dynamics. It lowers melatonin in animals, leading to fatigue, stress, and reduced immune responses.
• Insect Disruption: Roughly 50% of insect species are nocturnal, and lights disrupt their navigation and breeding. White LEDs are particularly harmful, attracting 48% more insects than older lamps, which leads to high mortality rates and biodiversity loss.
• Marine Life and Hatchlings: Coastal lighting confuses sea turtles, drawing hatchlings away from the ocean, killing millions of them annually.
• Plant Phenology: Artificial light prevents plants from adjusting to seasonal changes, impacting flowering, leaf coloring, and pollination.
• Soil Microbial Communities: Research shows ALAN destabilizes soil bacteria, favoring light-tolerant species and altering vital nutrient cycling (like denitrification). (DarkSky International)
Widespread Consequences:
• Biodiversity Loss: The disruption of nocturnal pollinators and insects has a cascading effect on food webs and overall ecosystem health.
• Impact on Human Health: Studies show that ALAN affects human health similarly to wildlife, contributing to sleep disruption, obesity, and, in some studies, increased risk of cancer.
• Economic Impact: The degradation of ecosystem services due to light pollution is estimated at over $3.4 trillion annually. (National Parks Service).
Reflect Orbital cannot be allowed to move forward.
Sincerely,
Name
Contact Info