04/25/2026
Graft choice in ACL reconstruction has shifted noticeably in the last decade, but there's still no single best graft for every patient. The right choice depends on your age, sport, activity level, and personal priorities, and it's always a decision we make together.
Here's how the main options compare:
Patellar tendon (bone-tendon-bone) has been the gold standard of ACL reconstruction for more than 30 years. It heals bone-to-bone on both ends and has the longest track record in cutting and pivoting athletes. The trade-off is a higher chance of anterior knee pain and kneeling discomfort.
Quad tendon autograft has become an increasingly common choice among ACL surgeons. It provides a thick, high-volume graft (with or without a bone plug, depending on technique), preserves the hamstrings, and tends to have lower rates of anterior knee pain compared to patellar tendon.
Hamstring autograft uses tendons from the inner side of the knee. Smaller incision, less early pain, but the hamstrings contribute to dynamic knee stability, so sacrificing them is a real consideration, especially in young pivoting athletes.
Allograft (donor tissue) eliminates harvest-site pain entirely but carries a higher re-tear rate in young, active patients. It's generally better suited for older patients or those with lower activity demands.
We put together a comprehensive comparison guide covering all four options in detail. If you're facing this decision, this is a good starting point for your conversation with your surgeon.
Quad tendon, patellar tendon, hamstring, or allograft? Dr. Jeremy Burnham (Ochsner-Andrews, Baton Rouge) compares ACL graft options using Panther Global Summit data, PIVOT trial evidence, and patient-specific decision-making.