11/13/2025
The Story of Professor C.E. Chrane
Part VI – The Trial of Tony Vriski
By the spring of 1931, Boonville had been waiting eight long months. The community that once spoke of Curtis E. Chrane only in sorrow now spoke his name with resolve. The man accused of his murder—Tony Vriski, twenty-one years old, an escapee of the Boonville reform school—would finally stand before a jury.
The Courtroom and the Opening Day
When the trial opened in Jefferson City on May 18, 1931, the courtroom was packed shoulder to shoulder. Reporters from St. Louis, Columbia, and Kansas City filled the press benches. Mrs. Chrane sat quietly near the front, her two young daughters beside her, the baby—born weeks after the murder—cared for by relatives nearby. The Boonville Daily News described her composure as “the kind of courage only duty to the living can command.”
Judge W. S. Stillwell presided. Prosecutor W. D. Semple led the state’s case, assisted by E. C. Lynch, Nile Bagby, and Mike Sevier. The defense, Lionel Davis and James Blair, seemed uneasy; rumors of an insanity plea had come to nothing. The trial would hinge only on the facts.
In his opening statement, Semple told the jury that Chrane had been murdered “while on a mission of joy”—driving to obtain a cradle for the baby soon to be born. The line brought the courtroom to silence. Even hardened deputies turned away to hide their tears.
The State Builds Its Case
Over the next two days, witness after witness retold the horror of September 9, 1930.
Henry Arpe, the gardener working near Sixth and High Streets, testified that he saw Vriski approach Chrane’s car, gun drawn, shouting, “Drive me quick to St. Louis!” Arpe pointed across the courtroom. “That’s the man,” he said firmly.
Joe Schultz, a neighbor of the reform school, followed. He described meeting Vriski that same afternoon:
“That’s a mighty fine gun you’ve got there,” I told him.
He pointed it at me and said, ‘Yes—and you’d better get along.’”
The jurors leaned forward as Schultz, reliving the moment, rose from his seat to demonstrate—until Judge Stillwell gently ordered him to sit.
Then came Colonel Theodore Ziske, superintendent of the Missouri Reformatory, who identified the weapon recovered from the scene as his own revolver, stolen from his home the night before. His testimony gave motive and means, painting a picture of betrayal from a boy he had once trusted.
The state’s most dramatic witnesses appeared on the second day. Wilbert Morrow, a farmhand near the highway, told how he saw the car veer into a clover field and heard the gunfire. And Harry Huckabay, the truck driver who captured Vriski, described the fight that ended the manhunt:
“He jumped on me and began choking and hitting. The car was going fast. He yelled, ‘Here’s where we both go to hell!’ ”
Huckabay struck him twice, dragged him back toward Boonville, and disarmed him at a filling station.
When asked what the prisoner said after being subdued, Huckabay replied calmly, “He said, ‘I did it. I’m in for it.’”
Defense attorney Davis pressed him—why hadn’t he mentioned that earlier? Huckabay’s answer brought laughter and applause from the gallery: “That was my privilege.”
Vriski’s Demeanor
Throughout the testimony, reporters noted that Vriski rarely showed emotion. The Daily News described him as “slouched and sallow, his eyes shifting nervously from juror to juror.” On the final afternoon of testimony he grew pale and blinked rapidly when witnesses pointed him out. The arrogance he had shown in early hearings had vanished.
The prosecution closed on May 20, its final image seared in the jurors’ minds: the cradle Chrane had never brought home, the gun that stole his life, and the students who found and avenged him.
Closing Arguments and Verdict
The defense offered little more than an appeal for mercy. Blair called Vriski “a victim of the slums,” pleading that “he is more a child than a man.” Semple’s rebuttal was sharp and unrelenting: “Justice to society at last demands that you find Tony Vriski guilty of murder in the first degree and assess his punishment at death.”
That night, the jury deliberated barely two hours. At 8:30 p.m. on May 21, they filed back into the silent courtroom. The foreman read the verdict:
“We, the jury, find the defendant, Tony Vriski, guilty of murder in the first degree, and assess his punishment at life imprisonment in the Missouri Penitentiary.”
A low murmur passed through the crowd. Five jurors had favored hanging, seven life imprisonment. In the end, mercy prevailed by a single vote.
Vriski laughed aloud—a short, harsh sound that froze the room. “Better for what?” he sneered to a reporter. “I had about as soon stretch a rope as rot in the pen here at Jeff City.” When Sheriff Prenger ordered him silent, he muttered curses under his breath.
The Boonville Daily News called it “a ghastly, peculiar laugh… as if the strings of his will had suddenly snapped.” For the Chrane family, it was the sound of justice unfinished but finally achieved.
The Attempted Escape
Barely three days later, on the evening of May 23, 1931, Vriski made one last bid for freedom. Guarded at the old Cole County Jail, he waited until a deputy opened the bull-pen door to remove ashes. Then he darted past and disappeared into the alleys of Jefferson City.
Deputy Dave Wright fired a warning shot as Mrs. Prenger, the sheriff’s wife, shouted the alarm. Vriski sprinted toward a creek north of town and vanished for half an hour. He was found crouched in an abandoned garage, hiding in the seat of a wrecked car.
“We ordered him out,” Wright said later. “He raised one hand, then the other, and said, ‘Don’t shoot! Don’t kill me!’ ”
His only weapon was a broken saw blade. Officers believed someone had slipped it to him during the trial. Within an hour, he was back behind bars. The next morning, he was transferred to the Missouri State Penitentiary under maximum security.
Sentencing and the End of the Case
Formal sentencing came in early June 1931. Standing before Judge Stillwell, Vriski was asked if he had anything to say before sentence was pronounced. “The jury said it all,” he muttered. Gone was the smirk, replaced by a dull resignation.
“The heavy locks have clicked behind him,” wrote the Boonville Daily News. “The gates are closed and the stone walls pocketed with machine guns rise before him as a relentless bar to his freedom.”
Officials doubted he would ever be paroled. Sheriff Prenger told reporters, “He’s where he can harm nobody.”
And with that, the case of State of Missouri v. Tony Vriski came to its close. The reform-school boy who had shattered Boonville’s peace was now confined behind the same walls he once fled. For the Chrane family and for the town that loved its superintendent, justice had not come swiftly, but it had come at last.