Simply Sarah's

Simply Sarah's Hello! I am a fondant free, buttercream only, home bakery! My passion is to create unique cakes! Separate Cake Pickup Entrance
(1)

💋❣️❤️‍🔥 It's Here! Let me know your pickup date! (Feb 8-14)
01/17/2026

💋❣️❤️‍🔥 It's Here! Let me know your pickup date! (Feb 8-14)

Sheet Cake Talk - 12x19 is my largest size, why? *2 cake layers with filling in between....serving more. *12 eggs go in ...
01/17/2026

Sheet Cake Talk - 12x19 is my largest size, why?
*2 cake layers with filling in between....serving more.
*12 eggs go in the mix....
*Approx 3 lbs of butter....(about $12 🤪)
*3-4 inches THICK....
*2 lbs (ish) powdered sugar
*Heavy Duty Boxing with 2 cake boards 🫣
*Takes up maximum space my kitchen & freezer has available 🤭
* Priced at $65

🐴🐄🐥
01/17/2026

🐴🐄🐥

Chocolate Lovers 🍫 💣
01/17/2026

Chocolate Lovers 🍫 💣

🥧 I haven't made a sugar Cream pie for years but had a craving and found a new recipe! What I like about this 🥧 is that ...
01/13/2026

🥧 I haven't made a sugar Cream pie for years but had a craving and found a new recipe! What I like about this 🥧 is that you bake on high heat for 10 minutes-which creates this caramelized crunch coat that is simply magical! 😋 I added more cinnamon to the mix, husband's request. It turned out perfect!
A small secret..... 🙊
☕️ I had some filling leftover and added it as cold foam to my coffee this morning! 😋 🤎
📃 Recipe attached for you!

When they say, "Oh..that's a Sarah Cake.." 💣🤍🖤**Birthday Celebration with a Cookies & Cream Cake**
01/11/2026

When they say, "Oh..that's a Sarah Cake.." 💣🤍🖤
**Birthday Celebration with a Cookies & Cream Cake**

Thanks for all the cake orders today! 🎂 Butterscotch 😋 🎂 Chocolate covered cherry chip 🍫 🎂 Turtle 🐢 🎂 Classic Cherry Chi...
01/10/2026

Thanks for all the cake orders today!
🎂 Butterscotch 😋
🎂 Chocolate covered cherry chip 🍫
🎂 Turtle 🐢
🎂 Classic Cherry Chip 🍒

🩷❄️ Baby Shower Set- with handmade white chocolate snowflakes on the cupcakes 🧁 😋 ❄️
01/10/2026

🩷❄️ Baby Shower Set- with handmade white chocolate snowflakes on the cupcakes 🧁 😋 ❄️

2026 Updates 📣 *I will be taking on a part time nanny position for a sweet baby girl next month! I will still be baking ...
01/09/2026

2026 Updates 📣
*I will be taking on a part time nanny position for a sweet baby girl next month! I will still be baking part time too! 🎂 👶
*I am taking cake orders on a month by month basis. Weddings/Large events book up to 1 yr in advance!
*My next cancer scan is in May. Pray for the all clear! 🎀
*I will be scheduling appointment times for cake pickups, as this works best for my family and work schedule. 💥Text or DM me if you need to change our set time!
*Valentine's Day-Once I know my work schedule I will post a menu! 💘
🧁 Thanks for ALL your support! 💙 S.

💣 New Flavors Coming Soon! 😋 ROCKY ROAD-Marshmallow fluff filled chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream, marsh...
01/08/2026

💣 New Flavors Coming Soon!
😋 ROCKY ROAD-Marshmallow fluff filled chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream, marshmallow bits, almonds & White Chocolate drizzle. 👏
😋 COOKIE BUTTER-Cookie flavored cake filled with Cookie butter spread and topped with vanilla buttercream, Biscoff Cookie & Cookie butter drizzle. 👌
😋 MATCHA-Matcha cake baked with organic matcha powder, topped with vanilla buttercream - or maybe Strawberry? 🍰

Coffee Cart this week will feature PB Cookies topped with milk chocolate drizzle & Reece's 😋 *Proceeds for Spain trip!*
01/06/2026

Coffee Cart this week will feature PB Cookies topped with milk chocolate drizzle & Reece's 😋
*Proceeds for Spain trip!*

Address

Defiance, OH

Opening Hours

Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Simply Sarah's posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Practice

Send a message to Simply Sarah's:

Shortcuts

Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on LinkedIn
Share on Pinterest Share on Reddit Share via Email
Share on WhatsApp Share on Instagram Share on Telegram