11/25/2025
I warn clients that it’s very easy in pregnancy to know you don’t want intervention. But that everything can sound appealing in labor. You’re struggling & someone offers a way to make the process go faster or be less painful? It’s a sad reality of our current maternity care.
.
I attended planned hospital births for 12 years and here’s one thing I learned.
No matter how much she prepared and talked about what she wanted for birth and her right to decline anything, even when deeply convicted about her choices, even when she KNEW it wasn’t in her or her baby’s interest, even when reminded of her options...
she’d often still end up saying yes.
Some things were honored and ground was stood, of course, and I know our preparation and my support there made a very substantial difference for those mothers. But almost always, the mother was talked into or immediately said yes to SOMETHING she didn’t actually want.
Sometimes “small” - a gown, an IV lock, peeing in a cup, stepping on a scale, a “little” monitoring. Often big - a vaginal check, breaking her water, making her lie down to push, antibiotics, clamping the cord early, a cesarean.
She doesn’t actually want it but in the moment she says yes anyway. There are hundreds reading this who know exactly what I’m talking about because it was you. You said yes but you would rather have said no or better yet, not been asked at all.
For some it’s people pleasing, a deeply entrenched need to appear to be a “good” girl and not cause trouble or have people upset with you. For many, it’s because your brain is literally different in labor. It’s highly suggestible and can’t access its assertive, critical thinking side. For a lot, it’s because they just need the incessant pressure (coercion, threatening) from staff to stop. (It’s kind of like someone shaking you awake at 2 a.m to ask you your choice for dinner over and over. Half asleep, you can barely comprehend what they’re saying and will say whatever shuts them up fastest.)
Whatever the reason, it’s not how birth is meant to be. It’s not how women should be treated. It’s not what God wants. It’s often the root of trauma.
If you choose to birth within the system (in or out of hospital), know this dynamic. Plan for this dynamic. And if you can’t be at peace with fully submitting or with compromises you will be forced/coerced/pressured to make, perhaps it’s time to choose completely differently.
🤍