The Not Perfect Cookie Co.

12/24/2025

Cookies for the office Christmas party!

Merry Christmas everyone. The Not Perfect Cookie Co. is signing off until the new year. See you then 😘😘

12/22/2025

A very special first birthday to “the ONE who stole Christmas”! Love how these cute cookies turned out!



PS. Why can I only add 5 hashtags all of a sudden?!?!?

12/18/2025

One of these things is not like the others… 🤦🏻‍♀️

12/11/2025

475 cookies delivered to for the annual Purse Bingo fundraiser!

11/29/2025

Small Business Saturday! I’ve been overwhelmed by all of the support this year. I truly appreciate each and every one of your orders - and I can’t wait to keep creating!

I’ve had several people ask me about Elf cookies. My December calendar is already super full, so I’m offering a limited pre-sale for personalized Elf cookies and cookie decorating kits.

Orders are open now through December 12. Pick up times will be available on:
•Thursday, December 18
• Friday, December 19
• Saturday, December 20

Here’s what I’m making!
• Personalized boy elf cookie - $5 each
• Personalized girl elf cookie - $5 each
• Cookie Decorating Kit - $20 each

All elf cookies will be vanilla-almond flavored made with all-purpose flour. I unfortunately will not be able to accommodate for any food allergies - sorry!

Cookie Decorating Kits will include 8 sugar cookies (shapes will vary - all will be Christmas themed), 3 colors of icing, and sprinkles. For gluten free, please add $4/kit. For dye-free, please add $5/kit.

Order by DM. I’ll message you back to get any additional information. Invoices will be sent out and must be paid by Sunday, December 14.

11/29/2025

Today’s cookies for - 100th Bucket Game!

11/28/2025

Only a few spots left! Sign up today!

Ready to sweeten your season? Join us at McAllister Rec Center with The Not Perfect Cookie Co. for a creative cookie decorating class filled with frosting, sprinkles, and holiday cheer! ❄️🎄

Whether you're a beginner or a decorating pro, this hands-on class is the perfect way to get into the spirit and leave with beautifully decorated treats (if you don’t eat them first 😉).

Register by calling McAllister Rec at (765) 807-1360 or online at https://secure.rec1.com/IN/lafayette-parks-recreation-in/catalog

11/28/2025

Congrats to the newest IU Columbus softball player! Rossville HS’s Finley Gibson signed her National Letter of Intent this past week, and was honored to make cookies for her big day. Congrats Finley!

11/27/2025

Some unique and beautiful baby shower cookies!

11/25/2025

Happy 2nd birthday to school bus-loving Tomás! I hope he had a great party!

11/22/2025

I made the “human treats” for Paws with Claus event today! Didn’t they turn out great??

11/17/2025

Last I checked, this class was already 1/3 filled! If you want to join me to make these adorable Christmas cookies, don’t delay!!

Get into the holiday spirit with The Not Perfect Cookie Co. in her holiday cookie decorating class at McAllister Rec Center! Join us on Friday, December 5 from 6-7:30pm to decorate Christmas themed cookies!

Registration is $40 per person, with a $5 discount for additional registrants in the same family. Call McAllister Rec at (765) 807-1360 or register online at https://secure.rec1.com/IN/lafayette-parks-recreation-in/catalog