10/15/2025
James Van Horn Jr.
March 13, 1808 - March 11, 1873
Section 7 Lot 6
James was born on March 13th 1808, the first son of James Van Horn Sr. and his second wife Abagail Carpenter. James Jr. would be raised as a farmer and trained in the family mills. His earliest business was a distillery in 1825, when he was just 17 years old. When his father retired in the 1840s, James took over the family's mill businesses.
In 1836, James married Malinda Niles, but less than a year later, she would die. Many local tales tell of James murdering his young wife, or her tragically dying by her own hand. Although there are many mysteries surrounding her death, it was likely she died from giving birth to James Jr's firstborn, James C. Van Horn. But you would have a hard time finding someone from this area that hasn’t heard the stories of her ghost still haunting the family mansion. Malinda died January 13, 1837, only ten days after her 21st birthday. She is buried in their estate graveyard. Malinda has become a legendary figure within the Van Horn Mansion walls, and remains arguably one of the most well-known of the Van Horns.
Later in 1837, the mansion was burned in a fire, and the family had it rebuilt. James Jr. also had to deal with the loss of the mills in a great fire, but he wasted no time to rebuild and continue the businesses. He also grew his business dealings, opening a Woolen factory in 1842.
In 1852, James built his own home on the family estate, just west of his parent's home. He married again in 1861 to Cecilia Davis and they had two boys. In their lifetimes, James Jr. and wife Cecilia were considered beloved Christians and great leaders in the community.
James Jr. represented his district in the State Assembly and would serve four terms as Town Supervisor. He was also involved in the many family businesses, although to what extent is unknown. By 1782 he decided to sell the family grist mill to a Mr. Arrowsmith (who changed the building's name to "Lake Shore Mills"). After Cecilia’s death, James Jr. moved in with son James C. on Ridge Road in Newfane, and he passed away on March 11, 1873.
Malinda is buried at the family home, Newfane, NY
-Read more about the stories of hauntings-
https://www.newfanehistoricalsociety.com/vanhornmansion_history.html
Sources- Newfane Historical Society