10/13/2025
How can journaling help you navigate your current life situation or work through past event that may still be impacting you? In this blog, Tyler Slay provides a valuable journaling resource to help you get started with using this tool. If you would like to meet with Tyler, or any of our CHH counselors, please reach out at 601-898-4947 or www.chhms.org for more help!
A Journaling Guide to Better Understand Your Story and Grow Spiritually
In his book, A Long Obedience in the Same Direction, Eugene Peterson tells this story about a brief conversation he had with a woman on one of his pastoral visits: “As I entered a home to make a pastoral visit, the person I came to see was sitting at a window embroidering a piece of cloth held taut on an oval hoop. She said, ‘Pastor, while waiting for you to come I realized what’s wrong with me—I don’t have a frame. My feelings, my thoughts, my activities—everything is loose and sloppy. There is no border to my life. I never know where I am. I need a frame for my life like this one I have for my embroidery.’”
I have come back to this profound little statement over and over because it has resonated with me so deeply. I’ve seen that what so many of us long for is a more defined frame for our lives – both our internal lives and our external lives. We desire to be a little less sloppy and a lot more purpose-driven, but we don’t know where to start on that journey. There is no such thing as perfection and there is no cure for being human, but there is work that can be done to better understand yourself and become more fully alive as a follower of Jesus.
If you are looking for a resource you can work through that will help you begin the process of going back into your story in order to go forward as a person and as a Christian, I have developed this journaling guide for you. What I have written below is intended to help you better understand your story and consider how God is working in your life.
Below, you’ll see headings describing six domains that I have found are critical to cover in a Christian counseling process. You will also see my attempt to concisely guide you on how to think about and write about each of these as you try to identify them in your own life.
1. Identify the Lie(s) You Struggle With on a Regular Basis.
What are you believing that is keeping you stuck?
Typically, there are two extremes: We're either trying to over-control aspects of our world that we can't truly control, or we are not stepping in and taking enough responsibility and leadership in what God has given us.
For example, on one side: "I’m functionally believing that God is not with me in this problem, and it’s up to me to fix it on my own." On the opposite side, many of our stuck points come from the belief: "There is no point in trying anymore because nothing ever seems to change."
The lies are normally more like half-truths than discrete lies, but they are lies nonetheless. Example: “God is with me in this problem, but it’s still my responsibility to figure it out and fix it on my own.”
What lies are you struggling with on a regular basis as it relates to your life, relationships, finances, future, spirituality, work, past, etc.?
2. Name What’s True in Response to Those Lies Logically and Scripturally
When these stuck points come up in your life, how are you responding to them with truth?
An example of naming what’s logically true: “My efforts to find peace through perfectionism and achievement haven’t produced the contentment and close relationships I long for in my life.”
In addition to logically naming what’s true, we must bring in what is true beyond our tiny ability to control outcomes. A great example is to bring to mind and spend time pondering Matthew 6:26: “Look at the birds of the air: they neither sow nor reap nor gather into barns, and yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are you not of more value than they?”
What’s true logically and scripturally in response to the lies you are struggling with? Where have you left God’s provision and ability to change hearts and minds out of the equation? Where has God provided for you throughout this struggle but you’ve missed reflecting on it due to fear and anxiety about the next thing?
3. Behaviorally Align Yourself with What’s True Via Repentance and a Rule of Life
A therapist talking about repentance? Even to me, that seems kind of out of place compared to the venues where I’m used to hearing that word. I love this clarification on the word from Eugene Peterson:
“Repentance is not an emotion. It is not feeling sorry for your sins. It is a decision. It is deciding that you have been wrong in supposing that you could manage your own life and be your own god; it is deciding that you were wrong in thinking that you had, or could get, the strength, education and training to make it on your own; it is deciding that you have been told a pack of lies about yourself and your neighbors and your world. And it is deciding that God in Jesus Christ is telling you the truth. Repentance is a realization that what God wants from you and what you want from God are not going to be achieved by doing the same old things, thinking the same old thoughts.”
I think it’s helpful here to actually write down what we are letting go of. Example: “I’m letting go of thinking that I can control my own destiny and provide my own joy via wealth and accomplishment.” Or: “I’m letting go of being afraid to be vulnerable in my marriage.”
If repentance involves more than just feeling guilty, then how do we decide to make this turn in an actionable way? We can do this via a rule of life. A rule of life is simply a structure for how you are going to live intentionally into what’s true. In its simplest form, you write down your daily, weekly, and yearly rhythms for prayer, relationships, leisure, and work. I recommend writing down the minimum rather than your highest aspirations.
For example, your commitments could be: Prayer: Pray and journal through Philippians 4:6–9 every day. Relationships: At least biweekly meetings with a group of people who take Christlikeness seriously. Leisure: Intentionally set aside time and resources to celebrate milestones and accomplishments, and commit to a certain amount of time completely away from work each year. Work: Set ambitious goals, but keep those within the boundaries of the previous three commitments.
This list could certainly expand. What about generosity, justice, service, study, and other spiritual disciplines? The point is this: even taking the time to intentionally define and commit to the four categories that we listed above would put you on a trajectory to live in a way that is governed by something bigger than your daily desires and anxieties. You don’t simply accidentally drift into a life well lived. Neither do you perfectly design and control your life to make yourself happy. Peace, we learn Biblically, comes only through a life of trusting obedience (John 13:17, Phil 4:9).
What sins and lies do you need to turn away from via repentance? What is your rule of life as it relates to prayer, relationships, leisure, and work?
4. Grieve the Wounds That Have Amplified Those Lies That Are in Your Mind and Body Via Lament and Forgiveness.
We Christians often ignore our pasts and our emotions out of some misinformed sense of spiritual duty. This is not the example we have in David, Jesus, or Paul. They hold the tension of emotional honesty without deconstruction of their faith. My friend Andrew Magers puts the necessity of lament like this in his book On Grief and Gratitude: “Because God is the creator of life, we honor him by lamenting when the goodness of God is denied in loss.” We honor God by longing and working for the restoration of all things, but that can only be done by naming and grieving what’s broken.
We also forget that Jesus talked frequently about the absolute necessity of forgiveness—we don't grieve just to blame the person(s) who wronged us. We grieve in order to communicate with God that we need his help moving on without bitterness towards Him and others. I don’t have space for a more full treatment of this step, but the basics are that there are two layers of forgiveness: the decision to forgive and then the working out of the emotions. To forgive, you must name pain. To name pain, you must face it and feel it. The decision to forgive is a choice that you can make, but it takes the emotions longer to catch up. Catholic writer Ronald Rolheiser puts the necessity of processing our wounds and working out forgiveness like this: “Whatever we don’t transform, we will transmit.”
What pain from your story are you transmitting to yourself and those you love because you haven’t named it and begun the process of grieving it? Who do you need to forgive who has intentionally or unintentionally harmed you?
5. Recognize and Own Your Unique Calling, Gifting, and Limitations
“God made you to reflect, in some unique way, a particular facet of his glory and his love out into the world. And when you are in Christ and in-dwelt by the spirit, you do that more and more. You become more uniquely yourself. Evil, despite what the media tells you, makes you boring. It shuts you in, makes you a clone of all sorts of other people who are doing much the same tedious sort of stuff. When you are seized by Christ and indwelt by the spirit, he will make you more truly yourself.” - N.T. Wright
If you’ll comb through your story, you’ll start to see a few important things clearly. You’ll see where people have routinely complimented and blessed some of your abilities. Is it possible that some wounds and insecurities have stopped you from being able to accept and step into some of the ways you’ve been blessed and praised? You’ll also see some giftings that cause you to come alive when you use them—some way that you relate to people and to the world that meets a need in the world and inside of you simultaneously. You must search diligently and curiously for this gift. It might not be found in a college catalog or job description.
Finally, you’ll see ways that you’ve tried to fit yourself into roles that have torn you down. Not all stress is bad stress, but some roles, jobs, relationships, and situations just don’t fit us or serve the rule of life that we are trying to live into. We can be a hero in one part of our lives in a way that causes us to totally fail in another important arena of our lives. The people that you love being around are often very aware of their limitations and know how to say no to what they are not called to and how to give their full yes to some place of need and pain in the world that they are called to.
What qualities and abilities have others blessed and praised in you that you haven’t reflected on or haven’t been able to accept? Is there anything you’ve ever done where you came alive and met someone else’s need simultaneously? What are some limitations, things you need to say no to or begin moving away from, that you need to name and admit?
6. Putting it All Together: Pray at The Edges of God’s Grace and Your Effort
The Bible is full of instances where our effort and God’s grace are not mutually exclusive; instead, we are commanded to take hold of both at once.
“Him we proclaim, warning everyone and teaching everyone with all wisdom, that we may present everyone mature in Christ. For this I toil, struggling with all his energy that he powerfully works within me.” Colossians 1:28–29 ESV
“Therefore, my beloved, as you have always obeyed, so now, not only as in my presence but much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling, for it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure.” Philippians 2:12–13 ESV
This effort may be best demonstrated by the Serenity Prayer that has been made famous through Alcoholics Anonymous:
God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference.
What is God asking you to step into to try to change, and what is He asking you to let go of for Him to change?
The reality of counseling, journaling, or any kind of deepening of self-understanding is that we aren’t capable of doing much more than naming and taking small steps into issues that we need God to heal. Yes, we can learn to communicate with more skill, feel rather than repress, react in ways that scientifically reduce anxiety rather than making it worse, etc. I’m a huge proponent of evidence-based psychological science, but even the most skilled application of any science or healing method only works if God, the author of life and source of all good, does a work in each human heart. Pray earnestly that God would do the work of making you more like Jesus as you engage in any process of self-understanding and self-improvement, and you’ll find that frame and border for your thoughts, feelings, and activities that you’ve been longing for.