10/09/2025
Was just talking about this to a parent today! Sharing because I could not say all this better than this person did! Worth reading ❤️
There’s a growing backlash against gentle parenting. It’s often described now as permissive, exhausting, unrealistic. A movement that makes parents feel guilty, never good enough. A parenting style that lets children run the home. That tells you to smile through tantrums, say yes to everything, and centre your child’s feelings while ignoring your own.
This isn’t what gentle parenting ever was meant to be.
But the truth is, many parents are finding it overwhelming. Many are walking away from it altogether, saying it made things worse. And that deserves attention.
Because somewhere along the way, gentle parenting has been misunderstood, both by those who criticise it, and by many of those trying to follow it.
It’s not gentle parenting that’s the problem. It’s how we’ve come to interpret it.
Too many people now believe that being a gentle parent means never saying no. That if your child cries or becomes angry, you’ve done something wrong. That setting limits is “mean.” That expressing your own frustration or needing a break is a failure.
But that’s not gentleness. That’s fear.
And fear-driven parenting, even if it’s soft and quiet, is still fear-driven.
Gentle parenting has never meant permissiveness. It has never meant self-sacrifice. It has never meant abandoning adult authority or control.
It does mean holding limits with empathy.
It does mean understanding behaviour rather than punishing it.
It does mean regulating yourself before you try to regulate your child.
But it also means being clear. Being firm. And staying grounded when your child can’t.
Gentle parenting says: I won’t hurt you to teach you. But I will teach you.
Why it’s feeling toxic to so many parents.
Gentle parenting, as it's commonly practiced online, has become perfectionistic. It's been reduced to a set of rules, how to phrase things, what to avoid saying, what never to do. Parents are bombarded with advice that’s often out of context and lacking nuance. They try to follow it to the letter, even when it goes against their instincts, their energy levels, their reality.
So instead of feeling supported, many parents feel anxious, hypervigilant, ashamed. Afraid that if they raise their voice or enforce a consequence, they’ve traumatised their child.
That isn’t gentle parenting. That’s parenting through fear of failure.
No wonder people are turning away from it.
A return to what gentle parenting really means.
At its heart, gentle parenting is not about behaviour management at all. It’s about relationships. It’s about approaching your child with the same respect and compassion you’d offer any human being, while still leading them.
It’s not soft or passive. It’s not an absence of discipline.
It is clear, calm leadership. It is boundaries, held without shaming. It is guiding children with kindness and confidence.
Yes, we understand the “why” behind behaviour. But we still respond. We still say “no.” We still move the child away. We still uphold rules that keep everyone safe and respected.
And we forgive ourselves for the hard moments. We repair. We keep going.
Gentleness must include you too!
The most overlooked part of gentle parenting is that you matter too.
If your child’s needs always come first, if you’re constantly suppressing your own emotions, if you’re afraid to hold boundaries because of how your child might respond, that is not sustainable.
You are not a robot. You are not a therapist. You are not immune to anger or exhaustion or grief.
You are a parent. A human. And you deserve compassion too.
The healthiest homes are not the quietest ones. They are the most connected. Where everyone feels safe, including you.
It was never about doing it perfectly!
The pressure to do gentle parenting “right” has turned it into something many of us can’t live up to.
The reality is that you will lose your temper. You will say the wrong thing. You will sometimes need space from your child.
That doesn’t undo the connection you’ve built. It doesn’t erase the moments of tenderness. It doesn’t make you a bad parent.
Gentle parenting was never about perfection. It was about presence.
Repair. Relationship. Growth. Over time.
Let’s bring the gentleness back, not just for our children, but for ourselves too.
Do you agree?
📕 For the truth of gentle parenting check out the new fully revised and updated edition of my bestselling “The Gentle Parenting Book”. https://amzn.to/47f2ovw