12/16/2025
I attended my first high school wrestling match Friday night.
Ryan, my CEO mentee, competes in the 157 weight class. I knew it would mean a lot for him to see me in the stands.
The ๐ค๐ฃ๐ก๐ฎ thing I knew going in was how the weight classes work.
Ryan's lean, quick, and technical. He only wrestles other guys in his weight class.
They don't throw him on the mat with some 285-pound heavyweight and wish him luck. Weight classes exist for a reason.
Most email marketers do the exact opposite.
They send the exact same message to everyone on their list.
๐ Brand new subscribers who just opted in yesterday get the same email as loyal readers who've been around for years.
๐ People who bought something last month get the same pitch as people who signed up for your freebie eight months ago and haven't clicked anything since.
It's like putting Ryan on the mat with a heavyweight and expecting him to win.
When you segment your list and match your message to where people actually are, everything changes.
New subscribers need trust-building. Engaged readers want value mixed with soft pitches. Recent buyers are primed for upsells.
Cold contacts who haven't clicked anything since they opted in need to be re-engaged... or cut loose.
Segment right, win more.
Just like Ryan.