10/12/2025
Judy Ann Herr, 79, of Cataract, Wisconsin, passed away peacefully on Sunday, October 12, 2025, surrounded by her loving family. Born on December 12, 1945, to George and Elizabeth Luther, Judy grew up on her beloved family farm, where she learned the values of hard work, faith, and family. She shared a joyful childhood with her siblings: Hedy Waite, Joan Sanders, Georgia Thomas, George Luther Jr., Randy Luther, Christine Stargard, and Brenda Luther.
On July 11, 1964, Judy married the love of her life, Donald William Herr I. Together, they built a home filled with laughter, love, and the wonderful chaos of family. They were blessed with three children: Kimberly Ahnen (Paul Ahnen), Donald Herr II (Lyndi Herr), and Melissa Herr (Jacob Wagner). Judy’s heart overflowed with pride and joy for her grandchildren—Aleshia Vieth (Matt Vieth), Benjamin Ahnen (Jessica Ahnen), Donald Herr III, Jenna Kast (Aaron Kast), Bethany Ahnen (Brock Craig), Laura Anderson (Tyler Anderson), and Lindsey Smith (Brian Smith)—and her great-grandchildren, Chase Vieth, Payten Craig, Lexi Vieth, RaeLynn Craig, Avery Anderson, Easton Ahnen, Jamesen Craig, Bryer Anderson, Raegan Kast, Oakley Smith, and Owen Kast.
Judy worked at Dairy Queen, Equity, and the Roma Pizza Plant, where she was known for her strong work ethic and cheerful spirit. But her greatest work was found in service to her faith and community. A devoted member of the Cataract Methodist Church, Judy led the Sunday School program for many years. She had a special gift for bringing people together through music and joy—organizing beautiful church programs and teaching children to sing. The annual Christmas program, her favorite event of the year, was always a highlight, reflecting her creativity, dedication, and love for the Lord. Judy’s kindness extended far beyond the church. For many years, she meticulously cared for the Cataract Cemetery, keeping it a beautiful place to visit.
She loved to bake and was often asked to make wedding cakes for friends and family. Her kitchen was always open, and no one ever left her table hungry. She taught her children that there was always room for one more, a lesson she shared with love through her famous recipes, many of which appeared in church and homemakers' cookbooks that she helped create. Judy was also a proud member of the Country Gals Homemaker Club and enjoyed snowmobiling, traveling, and taking her grandchildren to the ski hills every weekend. She cherished every adventure and every moment spent with those she loved.
Judy was preceded in death by her parents, George and Elizabeth Luther; her beloved husband, Donald William Herr I; her infant brother, Joseph Luther; her sister, Brenda Luther; her sister-in-law, Patty Luther; her brothers-in-law, Frannie Sanders and Earl Thomas.
Judy will be remembered for her unwavering faith, her boundless love, her laughter, and the countless ways she made life sweeter for others. Her spirit will live on in the hearts of her family and all who were blessed to know her.
A Funeral service will be held at 12 p.m. on Wednesday, October 15, 2025 at Cataract United Methodist Church, Cataract, with Reverend Loretta Waughtal officiating. Burial will follow the service in Cataract Cemetery. A luncheon will follow the burial, at the church.
A Visitation will be held from 10 a.m. until 12 p.m. on Wednesday, at the church.
Online condolences may be offered at www.schanhoferfh.com.
Lanham-Schanhofer Funeral Home and Cremation, Sparta, is assisting the family with arrangements.