11/13/2025
It's funny, when a local thinks about Robbie's Marina, we're not thinking about a tourist spot; it's a piece of our history, and honestly, a bit of an old Florida miracle still holding on.
Before it was Robbie's, the property on Lower Matecumbe Key was the Starck Fishing Camp, established by the Starck family who became the first permanent residents on that key back in the 1940s.
The building that's now the Hungry Tarpon Restaurant was originally their bait and tackle shop, and for years, it was just a local fishing hubโthe kind of place where you could get live shrimp, a cold beer, and the straight scoop on where the fish were biting.
It was rustic, authentic, and tied deep into the Keys' fishing heritage, long before the crowds showed up.
The whole thing changedโand the Robbie's legend was bornโback in 1976 when Robbie and his wife, Mona, stumbled across a massive, wounded tarpon floundering near the dock. This wasn't just any fish; his jaw was torn open, likely from a boat prop. Robbie, being a Keys person with a big heart, dragged the giant fish into his shrimp tank, called up an old local doctor, and they stitched the big guy up using a mattress needle and twine. They named him Scarface, nursed him for six months, and eventually released him. The incredible thing is, Scarface didn't leave; he and his friends started showing up at the dock every day, waiting for a handout.
That act of kindness is the core of what Robbie's is todayโthat tradition of hand-feeding the giant "Silver Kings" became the iconic draw, turning a small marina into something truly special.
From that simple, honest beginning with Scarface, Robbie's has slowly but surely evolved into the bustling hub you see today, though it still has that charming, laid-back grit. It grew naturally, adding more docks, more charters, and the Hungry Tarpon Restaurant became the perfect place to grab a cocktail and watch the main attraction.
As Islamorada became more of a destination, Robbie's followed suit, bringing in the open-air market with local artists and the jet ski and kayak rentals. For us locals, itโs a constant reminder of "Old Florida"โa place with character, a true origin story, and a sense of untamed fun thatโs getting harder and harder to find.
Itโs a bit messy, always buzzing, and you'll still hear those screams of surprise and laughter as a hundred-pound tarpon leaps out of the water for a baitfishโa spectacle born from one manโs compassion for an injured fish all those years ago.
HISTORY
History In Pictures
Florida Keys History & Discovery Center
History of Diving Museum
Addicted to History
Museum of Florida History
History Hit
Key West Historic Seaport