03/21/2026
Why depend on people when I can rely on AI?
"Increasingly, I see patients who expect perfect attunement, wise answers nonstop, extended availability, referring to how AI offers them these components. As if there is no friction, disappointment, or misunderstandings in real life.
How do you see this development, and how would you respond to such patients?" Thanks to one of our community members for sharing this question!
Of course, all of us wish for perfect attunement and understanding from imperfect humans.
But since we are human, flawed, and with limited knowledge, none of us can be the perfect fantasy others wish we could be.
No wonder we wish for an AI realization of our universal fantasy world where there is no friction, no disappointment, and no misunderstanding. For living in the real world with real events and real people, we will always encounter the friction of different desires, thoughts or feelings in others. Others will never be the same as our fantasies, so our fantasies will be disappointed (though we often think instead the other person disappointed us). And because your inner world is known and felt only by you, it is impossible for any person to know exactly what it is like to be you. Thus, our understandings of one another can only be partial.
Babies learn to bear this difference between fantasy and reality as children or as adults, but some of us never learn, always seeking that fantasy. Some claim that through meditation or some other practice that they have become the ideal. Others try to manipulate others into becoming the "ideal" partner. Then, supposedly, having found an emotional clone, no disappointment or friction would occur.
Now, some hope that, finally, at last, the fantasy emotional clone has been found in AI. So the question is this: does AI offer perfect attunement and perfect wisdom?
More importantly, can AI love a baby into being? Can AI love you?
What does a human's love offer you that the simulation of love by software cannot? Can a machine feel you, or is that something only a person can do? Does that matter to you? Does AI understand you and feel you, or is it just good at analyzing language based on being a Large Language Model? Does that matter to you? If not, why not?
Jon Frederickson, MSW
Author, Co-Creating Change: effective dynamic therapy techniques
The Lies We Tell Ourselves: how to face the truth, accept yourself, and create a better life, Co-Creating Safety: Healing the Fragile Patient
Psychotherapy videos and skill building exercises at:
Through education and training, The Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy Institute prepares therapists to practice ISTDP in a clinical setting.