11/12/2025
🚨 Federal Judge Grants Temporary Relief to PA Law Student in Landmark Smart Meter Disability Case
A U.S. District Court in Pennsylvania has issued a preliminary injunction preventing FirstEnergy Corp. from disconnecting utility service to 23-year-old law student Madison Rose Lucey, who successfully argued that mandatory smart meters exacerbate her documented physical disability.
Lucey, a second-year student at Widener University Commonwealth Law School with a prior master’s in data science, filed suit pro se against FirstEnergy and the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission (PAPUC) under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act.
She provided medical documentation stating that pulsed radiofrequency (RF) emissions from the utility’s advanced metering infrastructure (AMI) trigger severe neurological and cardiac symptoms, a condition increasingly recognized as Electromagnetic Radiation Syndrome (EMR Syndrome).
The court’s October ruling mandates that FirstEnergy maintain Lucey’s existing analog mechanical meter and refrain from service termination pending full adjudication—effectively pausing Pennsylvania’s no-opt-out smart meter mandate for this plaintiff.
📊 Key Facts from the Filing:
• PA Act 129 (2008) requires electric distribution companies to deploy AMI systems with 100% customer coverage.
• Unlike 18 states that permit analog meter retention, Pennsylvania offers no medical or technical opt-out.
• FirstEnergy issued disconnection notices to Lucey in July and August 2025, including one scheduled for her birthday, despite her physician’s recommendation for accommodation.
Research cited in the case includes a 2014 peer-reviewed survey by UC San Diego professor Beatrice Golomb, MD, PhD, which found 69% of 200 self-reported electrosensitive individuals identified smart meters as the primary onset trigger.
Golomb’s work highlights biological mechanisms—oxidative stress and voltage-gated calcium channel disruption—amplified by pulsed (vs. continuous) RF signals, with smart meters emitting peaks up to 900,000 μW/m².
“This ruling affirms that disability accommodation law applies to emerging environmental exposures, not just traditional accessibility barriers,” said W. Scott McCollough, senior litigation counsel for Children’s Health Defense, which filed an amicus brief. “If sustained, it could compel opt-out policies in mandate-only states.”
The decision arrives amid stalled legislation: Pennsylvania Senate Bill 600, which would establish a medical opt-out, remains in committee.
Similar bills advance in Massachusetts and Maine.
Lucey continues to represent herself while managing full-time studies, and a status conference is set for December 2025.