05/08/2025
A Facebook Post is not a Diagnosis.
โScroll with compassion. Comment with care. Diagnose with credentials.โ
โHeโs such a narcissist.โ
โShe must be bipolar.โ
โUgh, classic BPD behaviour.โ
โSheโs so toxicโcut her off.โ
You've heard it, even said it. Mental health buzzwords are everywhereโcomment threads, reels, TikToks, and captions.
Itโs tempting, isnโt it?
To make sense of someoneโs "weird" behaviour with a single label. Especially when mental health language is so widely used.
Hereโs the thing:
A Facebook post is not a diagnosis.
It's encouraging to see mental health topics like trauma, boundaries, attachment styles, and healing being discussed more openly. Increased awareness is a positive shift. However, there's a downsideโpeople are casually diagnosing others based solely on what they see online. Awareness is great, but labelling is not.
Diagnosing mental health conditions requires more than a snapshotโit requires a professional, nuanced assessment that considers a personโs full history, cultural background, context, and current functioning over time, as well as many other complex assessments.
Yet in comment threads and captions, words like "toxic," "narcissist," "bipolar," or "manipulative" get thrown around with ease. While these terms might feel accurate in the moment, misusing them can lead to mislabelling and misunderstanding.
Assigning a label can also be a way to distance ourselvesโfrom discomfort, from complexity, or even from examining our own role in a dynamic. True understanding requires more than a quick judgment.
By no means does this dismiss the real and painful impact of specific behavioursโor deny the existence of conditions. These struggles are real, and they can make life incredibly hard for everyone involved. Assigning a diagnosis without context, training, or consent doesn't lead to healingโit leads to harm. For all involved.
Hereโs why we must tread carefully:
โข Context matters.
Human behaviour can only be understood in its full contextโcultural, relational, and situational. What seems โabnormalโ in one setting might be expected entirely in another.
โข People are complex.
Our feelings and behaviours are shaped by many moving parts: stress, trauma, physical health, relationships, hormones, lack of support, environment and history. No one is reducible to a single label.
โข Stigma causes harm.
Labels can stick. They can shape how others treat someoneโor how someone sees themselves. When applied without care or accuracy, they can cause significant harm.
โข Social media is a highlight reel.
It canโt reflect tone, trauma, diagnosis, or intent. It rarely captures the whole truth of someoneโs inner world.
โข Therapy is sacred.
Real assessment requires consent, confidentiality, deep listening and many other modalities. That canโt happen in a scroll, comment section or video on the subject.
So next time you find yourself about to label someone based on a post, pause.
Choose curiosity over conclusionโcompassion over categorisation.
The truth is, most of us are just trying to be seen and understood, and we are all deeply complex beings. Yes, that includes you reading this right now, and me writing this.
So, before you label, think about this one...
โEverything that irritates us about others can lead us to an understanding of ourselves.โ โ Carl Jung
Be gentle with your wordsโ
They shape worlds.
xx