12/07/2022
The Failure of Traditional Mind-Body Beliefs
New book: Hidden With Us, A Radical New Understanding of the Mind-Body Connection
https://lnkd.in/eqJHc939
The traditional understanding of the mind-body relationship that has dominated popular and research attention is that the stress and emotional distress that we experience are the cause of many medical illnesses. Many believe that day-to-day stress and emotional distress are a direct cause of chronic medical conditions like hypertension, ulcers, inflammatory bowel disease, and others and that mind-body interventions are useful in treating or preventing them.
However, decades of psychosomatic research have failed to confirm this understanding. Yes, stress can indirectly contribute to illness through its effects on health habits such as overeating, smoking, substance abuse, and others. But, no, research has failed to confirm the belief that stress and emotional distress directly cause medical illness.
My clinical experience agrees with those negative findings. Yet traditional mind-body beliefs persist. In accord with those beliefs, the “psychosocial” history physicians are taught to obtain from patients continues to focus on their current day-to-day stress and emotional distress.
So, is there a mind-body connection? The answer is a definite yes. Yet what I’ve observed has led me to a very different understanding of this connection; one that is rarely, if ever, considered or mentioned. It is a perspective with important implications concerning our understanding and treatment of many widespread medical conditions whose cause remains inadequately understood.
I wrote 'Hidden Within Us' to convey that understanding and its implications. I will present this rarely considered yet unavoidable understanding as it unfolded to me. I learned that, to a large extent, the mind-body connection does not reside in the emotions we feel and that distress us. I came to realize that an absence of emotional distress does not preclude a mind-body origin. I was surprised to observe the unsuspected involvement of much more powerful emotions that, ironically, we don’t feel, and would insist that we don’t feel.
Evidence suggests that this connection pertains to a long list of conditions (among them, hypertension, chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, other chronic pain syndromes, colitis, autoimmune diseases, migraine, unexplained anxiety, and possibly many others) that are not well explained by medical science.
I do not believe that this mind-body origin is operative in all patients with these conditions. The proportion of patients in whom a given condition is attributable to this mind-body understanding differs from condition to condition. Even so, I believe it is an unrecognized cause or contributor in many patients and offers important, yet rarely explored treatment implications.
Hidden Within Us: A Radical New Understanding of the Mind-Body Connection