03/16/2026
"Science," like law, "is far from a perfect instrument of knowledge." History is littered with once-universal truths that have since come under scrutiny. Nevertheless, science is still "the best we have." — Carl Sagan, quoted by Judge Brian Murphy in today's ruling
That's how a federal judge opened his decision blocking RFK Jr.'s entire vaccine agenda. And it matters, because RFK Jr.'s HHS has spent the past year pretending that dismantling evidence-based vaccine policy was itself a form of scientific inquiry. Today, a court said otherwise.
Here's what the ruling actually means for you:
The 13 ACIP members Kennedy appointed after firing every qualified expert on the committee are effectively sidelined; they cannot meet in an official capacity, and every vote they cast is seemingly nullified.
The meeting scheduled for this week? Not happening... at least not as an official ACIP meeting.
The January memo that cut the childhood schedule from 17 routine vaccines down to 11 is now blocked. The hepatitis B birth dose recommendation (which had been stripped) is restored. These changes matter a LOT for what comes next, preventing further erosion of the federal schedule and restoring the legal and policy baseline.
For now, most families won't see an immediate change in what their insurance covers, as major insurers had already committed to honoring the pre-change schedule through 2026. But this ruling stops the damage from compounding.
The court was unambiguous: there is a method to how these decisions get made, one grounded in science and codified into law. This administration ignored it entirely.
This will be appealed. The fight isn't over. We are still processing the full implications of this ruling — and we'll have more for you as we work through it. But after months of watching science get sidelined, politicized, and replaced with ideology, today, we needed this win. And today, we got one.
TODAY, SCIENCE HELD.
TODAY, THE COURTS HELD THE LINE.
TODAY, CHILDREN WON. FAMILIES WON. EVERY LIVING BREATHING AMERICAN WON.
WE ALL WON.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/03/16/health/childhood-vaccines-lawsuit-kennedy.html?unlocked_article_code=1.TlA.Il18.6tmMNkrUyrDu&smid=url-share