02/12/2026
Not me, but like someoneās therapist in therapy that may be a DBT therapist could potentially dialectically do this. And by not me, I mean me, yesterday. Hereās why
In DBT the Pros and Cons skill isnāt just about making a better choice, itās about distress tolerance and surviving a crisis without making things worse by slowing down and getting back into our thinking brain.
1. Externalizes the Internal Conflict
When we are dysregulated our thoughts become a chaotic loop. Writing a Pro/Con list forces the brain to shift from the amygdala (the emotional alarm system) to the prefrontal cortex (the logical, planning center). This reduces cognitive load and allows you to view your impulses objectively rather than being consumed by them.
2. Highlights the āShort-Term vs. Long-Termā Trap
DBT Pros and Cons are unique because they require you to evaluate four quadrants rather than two:
šš¼ Pros/Cons of acting on the impulse.
šš¼ Pros/Cons of resisting the impulse.
Clinically, this exposes the āFalse Proā the fact that most harmful behaviors (like lashing out or self-sabotage) have a short-term pro (immediate relief) but a long-term con (shame, damaged relationships). Seeing this on paper breaks the illusion that the impulse is helpful. I call this telling the truth to yourself about yourself. ā ļø
3. Builds Wise Mind awareness and connection
the overlap between your emotional self and your reasonable self.
+ Validation: By listing the āProsā of a bad habit, you acknowledge why you want to do it (āit numbs the painā).
+ Logic: By listing the āCons,ā you acknowledge the reality of the aftermath.
This synthesis helps you accept your feelings while choosing a behavior that aligns with your long-term values. And itās an exposure to not acting
4. Creates a Urge Surfing Buffer
The act of physically writing the list creates a time delay. Emotions are like waves; they peak and then subside. By the time you finish a thorough Pro/Con list, the physiological intensity of the urge has often dropped below the blow s**t up zone, making it easier to choose a mor effective coping skill instead.
Inspired by the hilarious š«¶š»